Non-Invasive Archaeology and Truth and Reconciliation

Session Hosting Format: 
in-person session
Organizer(s): 
  • William T. D. Wadsworth, University of British Columbia / University of Alberta
  • Isaac S. Bender, TMHC Inc./Western University
Contact Email: 
Session Description (300 word max): 

Non-invasive archaeological methods have become crucial components in truth and reconciliation initiatives across Canada. Archaeologists and Indigenous Nations are regularly employing these technologies to answer a broad spectrum of questions while grappling with the associated complexities. Most notably among these applications is the deployment of geophysical and remote sensing techniques (e.g., ground-penetrating radar or GPR) to identify graves at highly sensitive sites (e.g., former Indian Residential Schools). While ground search techniques and results often dominate public discourse, in practice, non-invasive archaeology encompasses a much broader suite of methods, applications, and questions.

This session will explore the breadth of non-invasive research being undertaken within Canadian archaeology, with a focus on applications, challenges, and ethical responsibilities related to investigating burial landscapes and other truth and reconciliation initiatives. Presentations will showcase applications of ground- and drone-based geophysical and remote-sensing technologies; their integration with archaeological, archival, oral testimony, and geospatial evidence; and the complexities and challenges that come with conducting this type of work. Papers may also address issues such as data sovereignty, analytical uncertainty, trauma-informed and culturally-grounded practice, and the challenges associated with communicating results to Survivors, descendant communities, and the public.

Présentations
A revised interpretive method for identifying burials with ground-penetrating radar.
Format de présentation : In-Person
Auteur-e(s) :
  • Andrew Martindale - University of British Columbia

A core challenge in the application of geophysics to archaeology is the identification of subsurface patterns. Popular perception and common archaeological practice expect that specific subsurface features have relatively straightforward and unambiguous correlates in data visualizations derived from ground-penetrating radar (GPR) surveys. A more logical interpretive approach defines correlations between specific subsurface elements and their effects on reflected radar waves to define features as spatial arrangements of related traits. In this presentation, I outline the work of a global team to develop both a taxonomic assessment of human burial features, their associated reflective patterns in GPR visualizations, and the geophysical principles that constrain and produce these signal correlations. Such a template should have value in Indian Residential School landscapes and beyond.

An evaluation of the potential of lidar survey in the identification of unmarked graves within woodlots
Format de présentation : In-Person
Auteur-e(s) :
  • Edward Eastaugh - University of Western Ontario
  • Zack MacDonald - University of Western Ontario
  • Isaac Bender - TMHC Inc.
  • Adrian Burke - Université de Montréal
  • Micaela Champagne - University of Saskatoon
  • Peter Dawson - University of Calgary
  • Scott Hamilton - Lakehead University
  • Lisa Hodgetts - University of Western Ontario
  • Andrew Martindale - University of British Columbia
  • Kisha Supernant - University of Alberta
  • William Wadsworth - University of British Columbia

Lidar has become an established tool for the visualization and interpretation of large complex landscapes and as such is being increasingly used in the investigation of former Indian Residential Schools. It has already proven extremely useful for the identification of depressions formed by grave slumps in known cemeteries in open areas, as well as revealing structures and other larger features hidden within tree lots. Less clear is the degree to which lidar can identify relatively small and shallow grave depressions in woodlots as well. Are the more commonly applied lidar systems able to identify these depressions and can we distinguish them from the myriad of other complex topographic features, such as tree hollows, that we often see within woodlots? This paper presents preliminary results of an experimental study designed to establish the utility of lidar in the identification of unmarked grave depressions within woodlots and whether they can be reliably distinguished from other natural feature types.

Evaluating the use of multiple technologies for locating unmarked graves
Format de présentation : In-Person
Auteur-e(s) :
  • Lyndsay Dagg - University of Alberta
  • William T. D. Wadsworth - University of British Columbia / University of Alberta
  • Kisha Supernant - University of Alberta

Discussions surrounding ground-penetrating radar (GPR) have dominated many of the conversations around the search for unmarked graves at former Indian Residential Schools (IRS). While GPR has always been, and remains, a valuable tool in the search for unmarked graves, it is only one of many techniques suitable for this work. Due to the limitations of GPR,  it has long been argued that multiple technologies should be used in combination to produce more holistic results. However, the combination of multiple datasets can lead to interpretive challenges and requires a deep understanding of how different techniques complement or contradict each other. The Institute of Prairie and Indigenous Archaeology (IPIA) has worked to address this challenge, and here we present a potential matrix for evaluating the combined use of multiple technologies in the search for unmarked graves. Our aim is to highlight the myriad of ways multiple technologies can be combined and evaluated for a particular goal. We also discuss the importance of consistency, reproducibility, and accountability in this important work.

Indian Residential School investigations: interpretative context for remotely sensed data.
Format de présentation : In-Person
Auteur-e(s) :
  • Scott Hamilton - Lakehead University

Popular understanding of Indian Residential School (IRS) investigations emphasizes near-surface geophysics and drone imagery. These data are usually integrated with Survivor memories, archival records and ground inspection to achieve ‘multi-proxy’ insight. This requires interdisciplinary research teams, development of Indigenous technical capacity, and strategies for coping with information overload, analytic ‘silo’ effects and project management bottlenecks. This is easy to say but hard to achieve.

This presentation offers examples how historic imagery can further analysis by providing historical and taphonomic context for remote sensing output. It can reveal the evolving cultural geography of IRS grounds, and aid interpretation of Survivor testimony and archival texts.

While much has been learned since 2021, over 180 years of Canadian IRS operations cannot be addressed in less than 5 years. By 2024 Canada began stepping back from its commitments, with funding ending on March 31, 2026. What happens now? What about incomplete ground searches? What happens to information collected but not consolidated, analyzed, curated and archived? How do we face survivors and families who still don’t know the children’s fates?

Integrating Machine Learning Models with Aerial Remote Sensing for Enhanced Feature Detection: Automated Detection of Graves and Burial Features Associated with Indian Residential Schools
Format de présentation : In-Person
Auteur-e(s) :
  • Nick Kuncewicz - ARCH Airworks Inc.

Digital methods for site and feature identification are rapidly advancing archaeological practice, particularly through the integration of remote sensing technologies. However, many approaches remain difficult for archaeologists to interpret and implement, often requiring specialized expertise that is not widely accessible within the discipline. This is especially evident in investigations related to Indian Residential Schools in Canada, where transparent methodology and careful interpretation are critical, and where development and validation of findings must be grounded in quantifiable data.

Building on this foundation, this presentation outlines the development and application of machine learning models, pipelines, and workflows designed to detect and characterize burial features using multi-modal datasets. Integrating LiDAR-derived terrain models, RGB orthomosaics, and other remotely sensed data, supervised models are trained using a human-in-the-loop approach with annotated datasets. Current detection is driven primarily by image-based features, while patterns in grave morphology, geometry, and feature characterization are being documented for future integration with computer vision approaches.

Rather than relying on generalized “black box” workflows, this work emphasizes task-specific analytical strategies tailored to archaeological objectives. Results highlight both the potential and limitations of automated detection in complex environments, and underscore the importance of transparency, reproducibility, and careful interpretation in culturally sensitive investigations.

More Data, More Better? Evaluating Multi-Channel GPR Arrays for Burial Investigations
Format de présentation : Online - pre-recorded
Auteur-e(s) :
  • Isaac S. Bender - TMHC Inc./Western University

Multi-channel GPR arrays are increasingly promoted as an efficient means of rapidly surveying large areas at high spatial resolution for graves. This paper examines whether that apparent efficiency translates into more effective grave identification in practice. Although arrays allow for denser sampling and faster coverage compared to more traditional single-channel systems, higher spatial resolution does not necessarily produce clearer or more reliable results. Array workflows often place interpretive emphasis on 3D amplitude maps, even though the clearest indicators of graves are often only visible in individual profiles. This is particularly important because grave detectability often depends on subtle contrasts between the grave shaft, grave fill, and local geology. As a result, graves may only appear as subtle reflections in individual profiles while remaining effectively invisible in 3D amplitude maps. This presentation considers the often-overlooked costs of array surveying, including increased processing time and the data interpretation, storage, and sovereignty burdens created by these very large datasets. These limitations emphasize the importance of using geophysics in conjunction with other lines of evidence, including survivor testimony, archival documentation, local cemetery records, and historical landscape change, so that fieldwork can be directed toward the highest potential areas

Soil Spectroscopy in Burial Contexts: Parameters and Limitations
Format de présentation : In-Person
Auteur-e(s) :
  • Sara Lefurgey - University of Alberta
  • Talisha Chaput - University of Alberta
  • Kisha Supernant - University of Alberta
  • Élisabeth Cuerrier-Richer - Université du Québec à Trois-Rivières

Locating unmarked graves while working with Indigenous communities requires sensitivity, as the goal is to preserve the sanctity of these sites. As the search for unmarked graves continues, new technologies are continuously being developed for minimally invasive evaluations of the presence of human remains. One of these new technologies is the Subterra Grey (S4), a mobile soil spectroscopy and penetrometer unit. The purpose of this presentation is to present the current understanding of the S4’s capabilities based on data collected in collaboration with the Research on Experimental and Social Thanatology (REST[ES]) at the Université du Québec à Trois-Rivières. Soil spectroscopy can identify by-products of fat decomposition known as fatty acid salts, but they are not human decomposition-specific, leading to the problem of false positives. In combination, penetrometry detects soil compaction by measuring the force needed to penetrate the soil, providing insight into whether a burial was dug, but this is not grave-specific. Combined, penetrometry and spectroscopy can detect evidence of potential human decomposition and disturbed soil, but the parameters and limitations remain unclear. Through this presentation, the importance of clearly stating what a new technology can and cannot achieve, especially when working with communities, will be emphasized.

The Sturgeon Landing Residential School Project: Research Activities Beyond Burial Investigations
Format de présentation : In-Person
Auteur-e(s) :
  • Timothy Panas - Peter Ballantyne GOC

The Sturgeon Landing Residential School operated on the Sturgeon Weir Reservation in east-central Saskatchewan from 1926 until it was destroyed by fire in 1952. During this period, it affected children from sixteen communities across Saskatchewan and Manitoba.

Guided by the knowledge and advice of Survivors, and operated by the Peter Ballantyne Group of Companies, the Sturgeon Landing Residential School Project aims to research and commemorate the students, site, and history of the school. While a key component of this work is the identification of potential unmarked graves on the school grounds, the project also encompasses additional lines of inquiry identified by the community as essential to healing. Many of these approaches draw on holistic archaeological and anthropological methods.

This paper examines the Project’s current activities beyond the search for unmarked graves, highlighting how they contribute both to a fuller interpretation of the site and to the well-being of Indigenous communities across the two provinces.