Deep in Time and Vast in Expanse: The Dene Language Family in Western North America

Session Hosting Format: 
in-person session
Organizer(s): 
  • Kevin P. Gilmore HDR
  • John W. Ives University of Alberta (emeritus)
Contact Email: 
Session Description (300 word max): 

The story of the Dene language family starts early in the Pleistocene, a mid-Holocene inflection of Siberian origin, and eventual expansion to encompass many parts of western North America. The theme for the session will be broad, looking at the Dene experience from deep time to the present day, the initial migration south and west from the northern Canadian and interior Alaskan homeland to the coast of the current states of California and Oregon, the western Great Plains, and eastern Great Basin, and the eventual dispersal and differentiation of the different groups to modern homelands. We welcome a diversity of approaches and topics, and the intent of this session is to expand on the narrower focus of the Apachean Origins session at the 2022 CAA meeting in Edmonton to include all aspects of the Dene experience, from their arrival in the North to their role in the Southwest culture area as agents of innovation, trade and social evolution.  

Présentations
Adoption of the Bow and Arrow Across the Dene Language Family Was Not a Simple Process
Format de présentation : In-Person
Auteur-e(s) :
  • John W. (Jack) Ives - University of Alberta

Ideas concerning adoption of the bow and arrow in North America have surfaced over the decades, occasionally with reference to the role ancestral Dene people had in its spread toward the American Southwest. The Kehoes suggested the Avonlea Phase represented Dene people emerging on the northern Plains from the Subarctic bearing complex bows. More recently, Garvey et al. (2026) indicated that Southwestern arrival of Arctic derived complex bows “almost certainly reflects the retention of the technology by Apacheans as they moved from the Sub-Arctic.” These proposals fail to address several evidentiary flaws, among them the facts that: 1) late period bow forms for the Yukon and Northwest Territories are known, were adopted late, and were self-bows; 2) Inner Asian derived complex bows arrived with the mid-Holocene Arctic Small Tool tradition, but subsequently disappeared; 3) complex bow technology only reappeared with the Thule spread, now known to have occurred in the AD 13th century; and 4) archaeological, linguistic and genetic evidence indicate that Apachean ancestors were far to the south by then. Dene language family geography actually created multiple vectors for the transmission of bow technology to and by ancestral Dene populations, involving the Northwest Coast, Plateau, and northern Plains.

Ancient environmental DNA from a 6000-year-old moccasin preserved in alpine ice reveals biogeographic reflections of the distribution of Mount Edziza obsidian
Format de présentation : In-Person
Auteur-e(s) :
  • Duncan McLaren - Cordillera Archaeology Inc.; Department of Anthropology, University of Victoria
  • Tyler J. Murchie - Biodiversity Genomics, Hakai Institute; Department of Anthropology, McMaster University
  • Flavio Da Silva Coelho - Biodiversity Genomics, Hakai Institute
  • McIntyre A.  Barrera - Biodiversity Genomics, Hakai Institute
  • Christopher F.G. Hebda - Biodiversity Genomics, Hakai Institute; University of Victoria
  • Danielle Grant - Biodiversity Genomics, Hakai Institute
  • Libby Natola - Biodiversity Genomics, Hakai Institute
  • John W. Ives - Department of Anthropology, University of Alberta
  • Brendan Gray - Cordillera Archaeology Inc.

Alpine ice patches create conditions of exceptional preservation for organic artifacts and other remains that are otherwise rarely found. We report on an ancient environmental DNA analysis of a ~6000-year-old moccasin from the Kitsu Plateau in Tahltan Territory—a major archaeological obsidian quarry. Microscopy and shotgun sequencing of four components of the moccasin—the bottom and top hides, fur, and sinew—revealed a multi-species construction: top hide and fur from coastal hoary marmots (Marmota caligata), the thick sole hide from an ABC-clade brown bear (Ursus arctos), and sinew from northwest interior BEL caribou (Rangifer tarandus). Mitochondrial genomes were reassembled from all tissues, allowing for phylogenetic investigations of population origins, and various species of plant DNA were found reflecting alpine and boreal environmental DNA. Microbial DNA is consistent with communities found on leather and clothing, along with alpine environments. This composite biomolecular record reflects the use of animals from diverse ecogeographic zones, echoing the broad spatial distribution of Edziza obsidian across northwestern North America. This moccasin offers a rare, direct line of evidence into Middle Holocene human mobility, material procurement, and high-elevation land use, illuminating the intersection of biological and lithic networks in the subarctic Cordillera.

Bison ecology at the late AD 13 th century Promontory Caves: Insights from carbon and oxygen isotopes in serially-sampled tooth enamel
Format de présentation : In-Person
Auteur-e(s) :
  • Emily  Briggs - Department of Anthropology, Lakehead University
  • Jessica Z. Metcalfe - Department of Anthropology, Lakehead University
  • Chris Widga - Department of Geosciences, Pennsylvania State University
  • John W. Ives - Department of Anthropology, University of Alberta (emeritus)

Bison are the most abundant animal species found in the Promontory Caves of Utah during their late 13th century AD occupation. The presence of bison at Promontory Point during this interval was likely responsible for the intensive human use of the caves. Yet we know little about bison migration or the ecological contexts for seasonal bison hunting at Promontory. Were bison present at Promontory year-round, or only during particular seasons? Were bison skeletal remains obtained from different bison herds visiting the area at different times of year? To address these questions, we obtained carbon and oxygen isotope values (δ 13 C, δ 18 O) for serial enamel samples collected from six bison molars. Five molars had inverse relationships in δ 13 C and δ 18 O, suggesting the animals engaged in consistent seasonal movement patterns and/or were from the same herd. The sixth molar had an inverse relationship through most of its sequence, but also a short-term transition to higher δ 13 C and δ 18 O values. Strontium isotope analysis will help determine whether this individual made a brief journey away from its typical range.

Bridging the Divide: Toward a trans-Rocky Mountains Athapaskan archaeology in southern Wyoming
Format de présentation : Online - pre-recorded
Auteur-e(s) :
  • Spencer Pelton - Office of the Wyoming State Archaeologist
  • Michael Page - Office of the Wyoming State Archaeologist

The Wyoming Rocky Mountains lie between two widely recognized ancestral Athapaskan archaeological cultures. Sites of the “Promontory phenomenon” largely lie to the west in northeast Utah and sites of the “Dismal River Complex” lie to the east on the western Plains of Colorado, Nebraska, and Kansas. Many Wyoming sites have yielded Athapaskan pottery, but these data have yet to be incorporated within this larger body of research. Here, we describe variation in ancestral Athapaskan archaeology in Wyoming and present our current understanding of its age and location relative to more widely recognized traditions to the east and west. We then focus on the Willow Springs site, a recently investigated archaeological site in southeast Wyoming with a rich record of Athapaskan pottery and associated artifacts and features. We argue that sites of the Western Dismal River complex in the interior of the Rocky Mountains are key to understanding spatiotemporal relationships between the Promontory and Dismal River phenomena.

Dené Continuity at Doe’thu’choh (Winefred Lake)
Format de présentation : In-Person
Auteur-e(s) :
  • Ave  Dersch - Chipewyan Prairie First Nation
  • and  Chipewyan Prairie First Nation


The boreal forest of northern Alberta is often thought of as lacking cultural continuity due to population disruptions caused by conflict and epidemics from the fur trade. Winefred Lake, Doe’thu’choh, provides a counter narrative to this story showing continuity between Athabascan speaking Taltheilei people, the Dené of the historic fur trade era, and Chipewyan Prairie Dené hunters, fishers, trappers, plant gatherers, and businessmen of today. At present, the Dené of Chipewyan Prairie are fighting to protect their Way of Life in the face of rapid oil sands expansion all while ancestral (archaeological) sites are being surveyed and excavated without their knowledge or inclusion. Today archaeological excavations at Winefred Lake provide youth with a tangible connection to the hundreds of generations of Dené ancestors who came before them. These temporal roots provide the foundation needed to face the challenges that lie ahead such as how to ‘reclaim’ Dené cultural heritage values in post-oil sands development landscapes. 
 

Encountering the Ndee: Comparing the timing and economy Apachean settlement on the Central High Plains with other Plains Groups
Format de présentation : Online - pre-recorded
Auteur-e(s) :
  • Matthew E Hill, Jr - University of Iowa
  • Fox G.  Nelson - University of Iowa
  • Derick P. Juptner - University of Iowa
  • Margaret E.  Beck - University of Iowa

The appearance of Promontory groups in the Great Basin and the Front Range of the Rocky Mountains in the early 13th century created opportunities for ancestral Ndee groups to move into the Central Great Plains. The Plains landscape was already occupied at this time, however. Various Native groups, including Caddoan (ancestral Pawnee and Wichita), Siouan (ancestral Ioway, Oto, and Ho-Chunk) speakers and others lived in the Central Plains before and after the appearance of the Ndee. We address two under-explored issues related to the appearance of the Plains Apache. First, where were different groups positioned in the Central Plains before and after the appearance of the Plains Apache? Second, did the Ndee bring a unique economic focus to their new home, or were their subsistence strategies similar to other Plains groups? We answer these questions through a Bayesian analysis of more than 900 radiocarbon dates to establish relative chronologies of the 13 different Central Plains cultural groups before or during the Plains Apache occupation. In addition, we draw from a dataset of more than 100 archaeological sites to better understand cultural and temporal variation in the zooarchaeological record of precontact and contact period groups in the Central Great Plains.

Hide and Seek: Tabular Bifaces of the Okanagan Valley, Canada
Format de présentation : In-Person
Auteur-e(s) :
  • Joseph Jeffrey Werner - Okanagan College
  • Flannery Surette - Okanagan College

In this presentation, we report on a collection of artifacts from Penticton, British Columbia identified as hide softening tools, closely resembling “chitho” or tabular bifaces. These tools are typically made from coarse durable stones such as schist, gneiss, and quartzite, and were formed into thin minimally shaped circles, ovoids, or D-shapes. Tabular bifaces may have been used in the hand but were more often hafted to a thick wooden handle and pushed and dragged across the hide. Analysis of the tools is contextualized within a review of the ethnographic literature for interior British Columbia and the northwestern United States. What emerges is a broad pattern of continuity in hide softening technology across the region around the time of European contact and at least shortly before. As tabular bifaces are commonly associated with Athabaskan (Dene) populations of the subarctic, this assemblage invites discussion of how Athabaskan speakers might have influenced the hide working techniques of nearby Salishan groups. It also raises the possibility that the association between tabular bifaces and the subarctic is complicated and that the technology was more widely spread than is currently documented.

Jade exchange and Dene migration in western Canada
Format de présentation : In-Person
Auteur-e(s) :
  • Todd Kristensen - Archaeological Survey of Alberta
  • John Duke - University of Alberta
  • Jesse Morin - Simon Fraser University
  • David Meyer - University of Saskatchewan
  • Terra Lekach - Independent
  • Rachel Carroll - University of Alberta
  • Robert  Losey - University of Alberta
  • John  Ives - University of Alberta

Nephrite (jade) was used for over 3000 years in western North America to make ground stone celts. A small proportion of these labour-intensive tools were transported over a thousand kilometres east across mountains and linguistic boundaries to Alberta, Saskatchewan, and Manitoba. Nephrite celts are among the most widely dispersed artifacts in pre-contact Canada but lack clear utilitarian value in the regions to which they were traded; they may have been gifts or prestige items acquired by exchange. We link these artifacts to a chronological period that may overlap with Dene migration through the commercial production centres of nephrite celts in British Columbia. Detecting Dene migration has largely eluded northern archaeologists but jade celts may serve as a small and proxy indicator of a cultural and economic fluorescence stimulated by new Dene participants in the Plateau Interaction Sphere, one outcome of which was long-distance exchange of jade across the Dene world and beyond.   

Making Do with What’s at Hand: Recognizing “Resource Naivete” as an Approach for Identifying Recent Proto-Apache Immigrants in the Archaeological Record on the Western High Plains of Colorado, USA.
Paths of Persistence: New Evidence of Ndee Lifeways at the Foot of the Southern Rockies
Format de présentation : In-Person
Auteur-e(s) :
  • Jonathan Hedlund - ERO Resources Corporation
  • Marcus Espinosa - ERO Resources Corporation
  • Lisa Velarde - Independent Researcher

The Palmer Divide between the Arkansas River and Platte River basins in eastern Colorado, USA is often cited for its ecological characteristics and draw. Indigenous occupation on the landform has been persistent. This persistence remains true during the Middle to Late Ceramic periods (800 to 250 CE). Associated buried components, however, eluded archaeologists until recently. Since 2019, ERO Resources Corporation has completed excavations of six new sites containing well-constructed and lightweight Ndee Western Dismal River Gray Ware sherds. These ceramics occur in large numbers alongside well-made arrow points, large bifaces, hide-working tools, and patterned stone tools. Unanchored by complex hearth architecture and ground stone processing, the sum of the assemblages combined with the presence of obsidian, maize, and Northern Rio Grande valley ceramics points to a people who were technologically oriented around movement. This skill enabled Ndee people to thrive in places like Palmer Divide as well as ecozones typically avoided in the past. Cumulatively, these newly excavated assemblages provide insight into the lifeways of a people who traversed the Front Range of the Southern Rocky Mountains and influenced spheres on the High Plains and Northern Rio Grande River valley.

Phantom Hearths and Spilled Toolkits: Reading the Spatial Record at Eaglenest Portage (HkPa-4)
Format de présentation : In-Person
Auteur-e(s) :
  • Matthew Rawluk - Stantec Consulting Ltd.

Archaeological deposits in the boreal forest are often treated as diffuse and difficult to interpret. Shallow stratigraphy, acidic soils, poor organic preservation, and excavation methods that reduce spatial resolution all contribute to this perception. This paper argues that part of this interpretive difficulty reflects methodological resolution rather than occupational intensity, and that structured activity areas may remain unreadable when provenience is recorded at coarse scales. This problem is especially important in northern contexts, including discussions of Dene ancestral landscapes, where repeated occupations and shallow deposits can obscure patterned behaviour. The Eaglenest Portage site (HkPa-4), in the Birch Mountains of northeastern Alberta, provides a rare opportunity to examine this issue. Original excavations recorded artifacts in three dimensions, preserving spatial relationships routinely collapsed in standard mitigation contexts. Reanalysis using GIS-based spatial methods identified two patterned deposits within shallow, mixed sediments: a phantom hearth in Block C and a tightly bounded curated cluster in Block D, likely representing the contents of a container or bundle. Both patterns would be archaeologically unreadable under typical CRM recording resolution. High-resolution provenience can reveal structured activity areas that would otherwise remain archaeologically invisible.

Pipes and Puberty in Dene Languages
Format de présentation : In-Person
Auteur-e(s) :
  • Conor  Snoek - University of Lethbridge

This paper examines the semantic structure, etymology, and distribution of Dene words in two cultural domains with the aim of outlining their relevance for the study of Dene culture history. The Dene languages form a large family spread over a wide, discontinuous territory in western North America. The regional distribution of these languages has motivated grouping the Dene languages along geographic lines (Jaker et al. 2019). Supporting these groupings on linguistic grounds has proved difficult, both because of dialectological admixture affecting the clarity of the historical signal, as well as a paucity of data. However, recent improvements in the availability of data as well as in computer-aided classification techniques have produced better models of the phylogenetic structure of the language family (Snoek et al. 2022). The phylogenetic models still contain uncertainties providing difficulties for accurate interpretation. This study aims to overcome these difficulties by analysing the vocabulary for puberty and pipes from the perspective of Cultural Models Theory (Bennardo and de Munck 2020) and Cognitive Linguistics (Croft & Cruse 2004, Langacker 2008). The paper argues that the distribution of semantic patterns can reveal relationships between the Dene languages that are relevant to the study of history of these Peoples.

Pronghorn During Cultural Interactions at Promontory Cave 1, Utah
Format de présentation : In-Person
Auteur-e(s) :
  • Grace  Kohut - Lifeways of Canada Limited, Calgary, Canada
  • John  Ives - Department of Anthropology, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Canada
  • Hailey  Kennedy - Ember Archaeology, Sherwood Park, Canada
  • Joel  Janetski - Department of Anthropology, Brigham Young University, Provo, USA
  • Tatiana  Nomokonova - Department of Anthropology, University of Saskatchewan, Saskatoon, Canada

Promontory Cave 1 (42BO1), overlooking the Great Salt Lake in northern Utah, has been recognized as an important setting for interactions between incoming Subarctic groups, possibly of ancestral Dene origin, and peoples of the Great Basin during the thirteenth century CE. Decades of archaeological work at the cave have produced a substantial assemblage of faunal remains representing a variety of species. In this presentation, we focus on pronghorn (Antilocapra americana), highlighting its significance in these cultural encounters. Using zooarchaeological methods, we assessed carcass processing practices, demographic composition, and the seasonality of pronghorn use at the site. The fundings indicate that complete carcasses were likely transported to the cave, and that their heads were processed with notable care, as evidenced by traces of brain extraction and possible tongue removal. Demographic and seasonal analyses show that that both male and female pronghorn from nearly all age categories, from fetal to old adult, were consumed at Promontory Cave 1 during fall, winter, and spring.