Avancements de méthodologie et théorie en archéologie spatiale canadienne

Date/Heure: 
Jeudi, mai 6, 2021 - 3:20pm - 5:30pm
(CST)
Room: 
1
Organizer(s): 
  • William T. D. Wadsworth, University of Alberta
  • Scott Hamilton, Lakehead University
Contact Email: 
Session Description (300 word max): 

Diverses méthodes géospatiales et de télédétection deviennent de plus en plus communes dans les recensements, relevés et surveillances d'archéologie a travers du monde mais demeurent relativement peu développées dans le cadre de l’archéologie canadienne Bien qu'une récente augmentation de l'adoption de ces techniques au Canada soit observée, ces efforts restent en marge de nombreux programmes archéologiques.  Etant donné le caractère uniques et diversifiées des régions du Canada, les archéologues intéresses en télédétection dans ce pays sont uniquement positionées pour naviguer et explorer des conversations méthodologiques et théoriques innovatrices à ce sujet.

Cette session s'adresse aux participants intéressés par la recherche en télédétection, ou à ceux qui s'intéressent à son application.  Elle vise à permettre aux praticiens de débattre de la méthodologie, d'échanger des idées sur la visualisation et l'interprétation des données, et de débattre des défis de telles applications. Nous encourageons la participation de tous ceux qui s'intéressent à  la télédétection terrestre, aérienne, par stellite, ou sous-marine, à la prospection géophysique et à la manière dont ces données pourraient avoir un impact sur les aspects méthodologiques et théoriques de l'archéologie appliquée et académique.

Présentations
03:20 PM: Wally’s Beach II: Remote Sensing and Monitoring
Format de présentation :
Auteur-e(s) :
  • William T. D. Wadsworth - University of Alberta
  • Gabriel Yanicki - Canadian Museum of History

Southern Alberta’s Wally’s Beach (DhPg-8) is an archaeological and palaeontological locality of enduring research interest. Dating to at least 13,300 cal. BP, the site figures prominently in narratives of Clovis and pre-Clovis occupation of the Ice-Free Corridor during the earliest stages of the peopling of the Americas. Here, we summarize efforts to determine the extent of intact cultural deposits using three remote sensing techniques: aerial photogrammetry, synthetic aperture radar (SAR), and ground-penetrating radar (GPR). Each technique uniquely contributes to the overall prospection and monitoring of the site, complementing (and sometimes illuminating) results from surface/subsurface testing. Drone-generated orthomosaics and digital elevation models capture the site in stunning detail, highlighting areas of active aeolian and lacustrine erosion. SAR offers the potential to monitor these changing surfaces in real time. In addition to erosion, both provide views of parallel processes of deposition, the extent of which is most fully revealed by GPR. What appears to be a large infilled paleochannel—a suspected meander of the early St. Mary River—runs through the middle of the site and continues to trap sediment today. The banks and basin of this channel help delineate future targets for the recovery of buried Holocene and terminal Pleistocene materials.

03:30 PM: Magnetics: not just for finding your way in the Subarctic
Format de présentation :
Auteur-e(s) :
  • Jamie Steinberg - Lakehead University
  • Scott Hamilton - Lakehead University

Subarctic Archaeology can be a daunting task at the best of times; consider the large geographic size, difficult landscapes and constantly changing soil conditions. Acidic soil conditions destroy much of the visible organic evidence available to archaeologists. As the technology has developed, many archaeologists have considered the earth’s geomagnetic properties to document anomalies that could derive from anthropogenic origins. One such property is magnetic susceptibility which has proven effective in detecting hearth features in Europe and other regions of North America. The efficacy of the handheld Terraplus KT-10 magnetic susceptibility meter is being evaluated for archaeogeophysical surveys in the Subarctic by means of experimental hearth fires under controlled conditions.

03:40 PM: 20 Years of Magnetic Susceptibility Surveys: Lessons Learned
Format de présentation :
Auteur-e(s) :
  • Jonathan Fowler - Saint Mary's University

Terrestrial geophysical methods have been a core part of our research program now for 20 years. Over that time, we have witnessed significant changes in instrumentation, survey methods, and especially in data processing and visualization. This presentation examines best practices in multi-instrument surveys for archaeological prospection, site delineation, and mapping, with an emphasis on magnetic susceptibility as an underappreciated method for detecting a wide range of sites and features.

03:50 PM: Geophysical Survey at Nutana Cemetery: A Comparison of Ground Penetrating Radar (GPR) and Electromagnetic Data
Format de présentation :
Auteur-e(s) :
  • Terence Clark - University of Saskatchewan
  • Butch  Amundson - Stantec
  • James Hulsebosch - Stantec
  • Joshua Murphy - University of Saskatchewan
  • Angela Burant

Saskatoon’s first cemetery has 162 known internments starting in 1884 is located along the South Saskatchewan River. Many graves have stone tombstones and correspond to cemetery plot maps. Others have missing markers and due to slope erosion, some graves have been relocated and their locations are no longer certain. This project uses multiple non-invasive techniques to measure their correlation in both marked and unmarked contexts. Focus will also been placed on the differences in adult, child, and infant graves which the grave size and depth may vary greatly.

04:20 PM: ‘Stuff only drone nerds care about’: Evaluating UAV Photogrammetric Precision and Accuracy
Format de présentation :
Auteur-e(s) :
  • Scott Hamilton - Lakehead University

Consumer-grade (or ‘prosumer’) Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs) are increasingly used for mapping when ‘survey grade’ output is not required. While an attractive tool for archaeological mapping, uncertainty exists regarding the precision, accuracy and replicability of georeferenced photomosaics and elevation models. This is important when UAV-derived cartography is integrated with more precisely georeferenced digital data. This case study compares output from repeated flights over the same locality, using GIS to analyze the consistency of horizontal georeferencing and elevation models. While revealing horizontal georeferencing consistency within ± 2 metres,  dramatic variation in the elevation models is noted. While this variability reflects the technical limitations of prosumer UAVs, at issue is how to improve output precision and accuracy from such comparatively inexpensive equipment. One approach involves a RTK GPS receiver to independently determine the coordinates and elevations of Ground Control Points, and then their use to refine/correct the original photogrammetric output.

04:30 PM: Comparing Aerial Photogrammetry and Ground-based LiDAR for Erosion Monitoring
Format de présentation :
Auteur-e(s) :
  • Kelsey Pennanen - University of Calgary

From revealing to destroying, natural erosional processes have complex and lasting interactions with heritage sites. Accurate and detailed mapping is required to determine erosional impacts to a site over time, but this can be difficult to conduct using traditional methods with shifting reference points. Modern remote sensing methods can provide a means of monitoring change and allow for the creation of detailed models over large areas that can be compared at a yearly scale. This case study reports on the comparisons of using ground-based laser scanning (terrestrial LiDAR) over one year and aerial-based (UAV) photogrammetry over four years for quantifying erosional change at a threatened heritage site. Through work conducted at a buffalo jump on Blackfoot territory in Alberta, this paper outlines the determination of computational distance measurements to determine change derived from the two techniques using open-source software. Comparisons of the two methods including commentary on costs, time, accuracies, required training/permitting, and other considerations including data collection during adverse weather conditions will be addressed. Conclusions on the application of the two methods for heritage documentation and monitoring will be provided with suggestions to establish remotely sensed long-term monitoring programs.

04:40 PM: The Puzzle of Multi-sourced Data: From Aerial Photogrammetry to Soviet Maps
Format de présentation :
Auteur-e(s) :
  • Laurence Ferland - Université Laval

Technologies are both a bane and a blessing for archaeologists: they can make life more agreeable when allowing greater precision and saving a climb for that aerial picture. They also require training, or are not available when needed (even though the knowledge of their existence burns like red iron). Archaeologists are resourceful beings, however, and are known to make the best out of what they have. This applies to mapping using UAV and airborne photogrammetry. As amazing as they are, theses tools have their limits and may require additional methods or data sources to produce fully reliable maps. Happily, there is a wide array of open access and institutional databases which may provide lacking information. Though useful to fill in gaps and refine the precision of data acquired in the field, they also raise issues such as compatibility, scale, coverage, or ‘black box’ treatment where the manipulations that lead to the available product are unknown. In order to discuss these issues, two case studies based on aerial photogrammetry combined with ground data as well as external data such as Soviet maps and LiDAR tiles will be presented, namely Petko Karavelovo tell site in Bulgaria and DeEr-01 in Saguenay, Québec.

04:50 PM: Detecting Change at Threatened Heritage Sites Using UAV Photogrammetry: A Case Study from Qikiqtaruk, Yukon
Format de présentation :
Auteur-e(s) :
  • Katelyn O'Keefe - University of Calgary

The heritage features on Qikiqtaruk (formerly known as Herschel Island), Yukon, represent a long period of occupation, from 800 years ago to the present. Pauline Cove, the island's most culturally significant area, has the most heritage features. These features include Inuvialuit sod houses and historic buildings associated with the whaling period, fur trade, missionaries, and the RCMP. Unfortunately, coastal erosion and inland flooding events associated with a changing climate are putting these features at risk. Aerial imagery of Pauline Cove was taken in July 2017 and July 2019 using an unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV, i.e., Drone). By comparing orthomosaics and point clouds generated from each respective year, changes to the heritage features and the landscape have been detected and documented. First, heritage-rich segments of the orthomosaics of Pauline Cove were compared using visual inspection. Second, change-detection analysis was performed on the point-clouds to quantify the differences between the two years. Together, these methods elucidate the impact of flooding, erosion, and researcher activities on Pauline Cove's heritage. Furthermore, the low-cost, streamlined procedures can be applied to develop a monitoring strategy for heritage at Pauline Cove and other circumpolar environments. 

05:00 PM: FROM A BIRD’S EYE VIEW. APPLICATION OF UNMANNED AERIAL VEHICLES IN HISTORICAL RESOURCES IMPACT ASSESSMENTS.
Format de présentation :
Auteur-e(s) :
  • Petr Kurzybov - Western Heritage Services Inc.
  • Michael Ma - Western Heritage Services Inc.
  • Daniel Lu - Western Heritage Services Inc.

One of the goals of CRM is to mitigate impacts to historic resources created by various industrial developments. Recognizing, describing, and classifying these impacts are complex tasks usually addressed within traditional historic resource impact assessment (HRIA). Rapidly developing Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs) technologies have potential to change that. UAVs have become widespread in industrial settings, archaeological research and CRM, and allow users to acquire rapid and inexpensive fine-resolution imagery using a variety of sensors. Their affordability, versatility, and flexibility give them an advantage over other means of acquiring remote-sensing data (e.g., ortho or satellite imagery). Advancements in software for processing imagery (i.e., artificial intelligence) have also opened up many new opportunities.

Western Heritage tested one application of UAVs in a small pilot project in the boreal zone of Northwestern Alberta. The project's goal was to acquire and analyze landscape imagery to identify and classify land disturbances created during forest harvest. This pilot study's preliminary results demonstrated the potential benefits of this method and clarified its advantages and challenges. Results of this study will help to inform and potentially define historical resource impact assessment (HRIA) strategies.