Papers in Honour of Dr. Brian (Barney) Reeves

Session Hosting Format: 
in-person session
Organizer(s): 
  • Dr, Alison Landals, Stantec
  • Dr. Margaret Kennedy
Contact Email: 
Session Description (300 word max): 

Even though it has been three years since Brian (Barney) Reeves died in August of 2023, it is a testament to his profound impact on the field of archaeology and more importantly on his former students, colleagues and friends that we gather in Canmore to remember and celebrate his impressive legacy. The papers to be presented at this session reflect Barney’s influences and foundational ideas in archaeology - his major contributions to Plains/Mountain culture history and classification through his pioneering recording programs in Waterton National Park and the Crowsnest Pass, his deep interest in northern plains ethnography, ethnobotany, communal bison hunting (Head-Smashed-In), archaeoastronomy and ceremonial landscapes, all of which was enhanced by his decades-long and close friendship with a number of Piikani elders. Also to be considered was his amazingly wide first-hand familiarity with the archaeological literature and artifact collections inside and outside of the plains and his impressive ability to synthesize vast quantities of information into comprehensive models of culture history. He brought an insatiable curiousity and dedication to the research he took on and profoundly influenced many of us throughout our careers.  The papers to be given in this session honour his memory and personality, his ongoing academic legacy and highlight the large number and variety of contributions he made to archaeology.

Presentations
APPLYING THE CONCEPT OF “CEREMONIAL LANDSCAPES” IN NORTH-CENTRAL MONTANA ( Patrick Rennie )
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Patrick Rennie - Montana DNRC (State of Montana)

An opportunity arose in north-central Montana to apply and test Reeves and Kennedy’s (2017) concept of “Ceremonial Landscapes”.  Firstly, this opportunity resulted from two different types of medicine wheels being situated within two distinct 2,500-acre blocks of State land.  Secondly, the opportunity arose because the State of Montana began purchasing drones for a variety of field applications in 2018.  Drone photography and advances in GIS technology allow efficient and accurate documentation of large-scale areas that contain hundreds of stone features.  The two subject Montana Ceremonial Landscapes are 70 miles/113 km apart and approximately 180 miles/290 km from the general area investigated by Reeves and Kennedy (2017) in southeastern Alberta/southwestern Saskatchewan.  A seven-year study of the two Montana localities demonstrates many similarities with the Reeves and Kennedy (2017) study, thereby validating the importance of inventorying large scale areas around medicine wheels and documenting ancillary features.

Reference Cited:

Reeves, Brain O.K., and Margaret A. Kennedy

2017    Stone Feature Types at Ceremonial Site Complexes on the Lower Red Deer and the

Forks of the Red Deer and South Saskatchewan Rivers with Ethnohistorical Discussion. Archaeology in Montana 58(1):1-44.

Ceramic Diversity During the Terminal Precontact Period of the Canadian Plains: Implications and Challenges ( Dale Walde )
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Dale Walde - None

This paper summarizes progress on an ongoing Canadian Plains ceramic distribution and typology project. For this summary some of the diversity of the many types of pottery present on the Canadian Plains during the Terminal Precontact period (ca 1100 rcybp to Contact). The spatial and temporal distributions of these types are discussed. A discussion of the implications of the diversity of the detailed and well–preserved archaeological record available to Canadian Plains archaeologists is initiated and a few thoughts as to the relationships of that diversity to, among other things, present–day land claims and ethnohistory.

Contributed Personal Reminiscences of Barney Reeves ( Various Contributors )
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Various Contributors

Some of Barney's former friends and students (Laurie Milne, Ann Johnson and Philip Duke) were unable to attend the conference but still wanted to relay their personal memories and comments about Barney and have provided written submissions on these recollections for this session.    These short poignant, telling and sometimes humorous reminiscences will be read aloud by the co-chairs and well worth your time to listen to.

Counter-mapping the Blackfoot Landscape ( Gerald Oetelaar )
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Gerald Oetelaar - University of Calgary
  • D. Joy Oetelaar

Recently, we have adopted counter-mapping as an alternative approach to interpret the archaeological record of the Northwestern Plains as an imprint of Blackfoot oral traditions. Counter-mapping involves the production of maps of culturally inscribed landscapes of particular groups as a counter to western maps that misrepresent these landscapes. Based on the Cartesian grid, western maps display the geology, topography, hydrology, flora, and fauna as defined by disciplinary specialists. Archaeologists use these data to create the stage and model human behaviour according to a western understanding of the world. To counter map this landscape, researchers must begin by accepting the Blackfoot understanding of the world and thus creating a stage that establishes connections between oral traditions, maps, toponyms and archaeological sites. Using this approach, the homeland of the Blackfoot becomes a managed landscape serving as an archive of Blackfoot oral traditions. Once restricted to reservations, the Blackfoot could no longer visit the places, remember the names, tell the stories, sing the songs, perform the ceremonies, and transmit this information to subsequent generations. Colonization was therefore so much more than the extermination of bison and the appropriation of the homeland.

Illuminated Rocks: Sourcing and Paleoindian Use of Quartz Crystals in the Western U.S. ( Daniel Meatte )
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Daniel Meatte - Washington State Parks (Retired)

A well-established hallmark of Clovis people’s stone tool use in the western U. S. is their preference for high quality exotic cherts procured from distant stone quarries. There are numerous examples of stone being transported hundreds of kilometers from quarries to their point of use. Other materials such as chalcedony, obsidian and even quartz crystal also fit this pattern. One rare material, quartz crystal, is examined here to determine where it is sourced from, how it is procured and the size ranges available for use. Findings show that large quartz crystals are limited to pegmatite deposits found in exposed granitic batholiths in parts of California and the northern Rocky Mountains in central Idaho and southwestern Montana. Large crystals in excess of 30cm in diameter are reported. Unique mineral characteristics such as triboluminescence and light refraction suggest, that when coupled with the broader interest in exotic lithics, it is the mineral properties themselves that are selected for.  Color, texture, chatoyancy, patterning, smoothness, and optical properties. The choice to use exotic lithics to manufacture select Clovis tools may involve more than functional attributes of durability and sharp edges. It also involves thoughtful incorporation and displays of specific mineral properties.

REEVES: FIRST ENCOUNTERS ( Bill Byrne )
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Bill Byrne

My long a d convoluted history with Brian Olfert Kemmis Reeves began with my first exposure to archaeological field work in 1963. I had just completed my freshman year at what was then called "The UNiversity of Alberta at Calgary" when the university did not yet have a Department of Archaeology but had announced that one would be established in the coming academic year.  Barney had already been accpeted as a graduate student in the forthcoming department.  That year he was still employed by the Glenbow Museum, and the project I was to participate in with him that summer was funded by and executed by the same instution.  That began a memorable journey for both of us, with our professional and personal association persisting for the best part of the nxt many decades. My comments will relate some of those earliest moments.

Snakes in the Grass: Eighteenth-Century ‘Plains’ Shoshone on the Northwestern Plains ( Trevor Peck )
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Trevor Peck - Synergy Land and Environmental Services

Authorities generally agree that eighteenth-century historical documents support the position that the ‘Snake’ were on the northwestern plains prior to, and during the fur trade. The use of references to the Snake on the Canadian portion of the northwestern plains at this time, however, are often limited to a few well-known citations such as the recounting of Saukamappee’s saga by David Thompson. These citations have been used to argue for an early eighteen-century presence of the Shoshone in southern Alberta followed by a retreat, owing to the smallpox epidemic and inferior access to fur trade guns. While not disputing this general scenario, this paper provides a more comprehensive review of oral tradition and historical documents that record the ‘Snake’ on the plains of Canada. Evidence is provided to reaffirm the Snake-Shoshone connection as well as to establish clarity regarding the extent and nature of their presence on the northwestern Plains.

Ten Thousand Years and Six Decades of Archaeology in the Crowsnest Pass ( Margaret  Kennedy )
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Margaret  Kennedy - retired

In 1958 Richard G. Forbis recorded the first site in the DjPp Borden Block in the Crowsnest Pass– the pictographs in the cave on Crowsnest Lake.  He and his assistant from the Glenbow Foundation’s newly established Department of Archaeology completed a few more site recordings elsewhere in the Pass but no further investigations took place at that time. That came about through the work of Dr. Brian (Barney) O.K. Reeves, to whom most of the credit for our understanding of the archaeology of the Pass is due.  His work there began with a major three-year program of survey and site excavations in 1972, 1973 and 1974, and continued over following years through a mix of field schools, salvage work and graduate student research.  Lifeways of Canada Ltd., established by Barney in 1972 and the first heritage consulting company in Alberta, conducted almost all CRM projects in the Pass for a number of years and I can bring a personal perspective to some of that work.  I will reflect on Barney’s contributions to Crowsnest Pass archaeology, review work done in recent years and revisit ideas of past human use of this intensively studied and important Rocky Mountain pass.

The Right Ways – Lifeways’ 54 Years (and counting) in Consulting Archaeology ( Brian Vivian )
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Brian Vivian - Lifeways of Canada Limited, Calgary, Canada
  • Claire Bourges - Lifeways of Canada Limited

In partnership with two other colleagues, Barney Reeves founded Lifeways of Canada in 1972. Lifeways was the frist Historical Resource Consulting firm in Western Canada. Over its fifty-four years of operation, Lifeways has remained steadfast in undertaking Historical Resource Assessments, implementing major surveys, and completing large-scale excavations that have contributed significantly to the archaeology of the regions the company has worked in.  In this paper we focus on Barney Reeves, examine the directions he set for Lifeways, and review the impact Barney's tutelage has had on the development of consulting archaeology in Western Canada.

What Goes Around Comes Around: Adoptions and Adaptations of Archaeological Theory in the Past Excavations at Head-Smashed-In Buffalo Jump ( Shawn Bubel )
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Shawn Bubel - University of Lethbridge
  • Kevin McGeough - University of Lethbridge
Inspired by a presentation on the past and future of Alberta archaeology delivered by Barney Reeves at the 40th Anniversary of the Archaeological Society of Alberta, this paper explores how the excavators of Head-Smashed-In Buffalo Jump have driven the theoretical approaches to archaeology in the province. As one of the most internationally recognized sites in Alberta, excavations at Head-Smashed-In Buffalo Jump have both mirrored and defied the trends in archaeological theory in other parts of North America and the world. Barney Reeves, for example, in his work at HSIBJ, offered an approach to Alberta prehistory that merged culture-historical methods with insights derived from cultural ecology and Parsonian processualism that came to be idiosyncratically foundational for archaeology in the province. This paper will discuss the theoretical contributions of Reeves and other previous investigators, such as Junius Bird and Boyd Wettlaufer, and examine how those contributions reflect larger trends in the development of archaeological theory and method in Alberta.
X Marks the Spot: How Reeves’ Forgotten Excavation Unit Rewrites the Chronology of Head-Smashed-In Buffalo Jump ( Matthew Sawchuk )
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Matthew Sawchuk

Head-Smashed-In Buffalo Jump is the longest used and oldest confirmed bison jump. The results of excavations in the kill site by Reeves led him to propose that there was a hiatus in the use of the site between 3 100 and 900 BCE. In an effort to better understand this hiatus, a stratigraphic column of Reeves' excavations was constructed based on his field notes and boxes of faunal remains curated by the Royal Alberta Museum. His hypothesis is principally based upon the large sterile levels in Units A and Z. Intriguingly, the corresponding levels of Unit X contain lots of butchered bone but no artifacts. New C14 dates were obtained from the bones in Unit X and his north excavation area to investigate these levels and early uses of HISBJ. By combining Reeves' original work with the results of the subsequent half-century of new research at HSIBJ, we conclude that the site saw continuous use from 6 600 BP until the 1800s. The makers of Oxbow points are the most likely group to have used the site during the previously proposed Gap. This discovery expands our knowledge of Great Plains bison hunting traditions during the Middle Precontact Period.

“Our Mountains are our Pillows”: Towards a Piikáni Sacred Ecology ( Sandra Peacock )
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Sandra Peacock - University of British Columbia - Okanagan

 “Our Mountains are our Pillows” is the title of an ethnographic overview Barney (Brian) Reeves and I worked on over 30 years ago for the US National Parks Service to document the traditional activities of the Piikáni peoples, and others, within the boundaries of Glacier National Park (Reeves & Peacock 2001).  This paper highlights aspects of our multi-year collaboration with Piikáni elders and spiritual leaders in Alberta and Montana, including our extensive ethnobotanical and ethnohistorical fieldwork and the unique perspectives Barney brought to the research.  It concludes by suggesting this work moves beyond a utilitarian management perspective to describe a sacred ecology of the Piikáni peoples, an integration of their traditional beliefs, practices and ecological stewardship centered along Mistakis – the “backbone” – the eastern slopes of the Rocky Mountains. 

03:20 PM: Ascribing ethnicity to ceremonial stone feature landscapes: Reeves’ Old Women’s and Avonlea phase definitions, and the many potential homelands of the Gros Ventre/White Clay People ( Alison Landals )
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Alison Landals - Stantec Consulting Ltd.

Brian Reeves’ 1970 definition of the Old Women’s phase did not ascribe it to any ethnic affiliation, following the strict, established convention of those times. However, by placing it within his “Napikwan” tradition, it was clear that he conceived the Phase as ancestral to Algonkian speaking peoples.  When his dissertation was eventually published in 1983, he clarified that he saw the Phase as ancestral to both the Blackfoot and Gros Ventre people. Over the succeeding decades multiple researchers have focused on more fully describing Old Women’s material culture and phase indicators, its temporal/geographic extent and especially its ethnic affiliation; the sheer strength of the correlation of this phase with the ancestral Blackfoot went from “daring” to “dogma” in a generation. At the same time, any place for the Gros Ventre within the Old Women’s phase has dwindled into irrelevance and invisibility. This paper will consider reasons for this situation and Reeves’ more recent attempt to ascribe Gros Ventre affiliation to stone features within the Forks ceremonial landscape. Alternate phase associations for the Gros Ventre are also considered.