“The Expedition excites the strongest interest”: Recent Archaeology, Research and Public Presentation on Sir John Franklin’s 1845 Northwest Passage Expedition

Session Hosting Format: 
in-person session
Organizer(s): 
  • Jonathan Moore, Parks Canada
Contact Email: 
Session Description (300 word max): 

On May 19, 1845, on the day of the departure of HMS Erebus and HMS Terror from England for a renewed search for a Northwest Passage, Captain Sir John Franklin wrote that “The Expedition excites the strongest interest in England among all parties and likewise on the Continent”. This statement is as true today as it was in 1845, even more so. Franklin could scarcely have imagined how that public interest transformed from hope for success, anxiety over the missing crews and ships, knowledge learned from Inuit about sunken ships and cannibalism, and ultimately the public craving for archaeological evidence for an expedition that had come undone by April 1848. Archaeological study of the expedition, both terrestrial and underwater, can be traced back to the early 1960s, and has steadily progressed, both through individual projects and bursts of activity. A renewed archaeological search for the wrecks of Erebus and Terror and terrestrial archaeological evidence launched in 2008, and the locating of the wrecks in 2014 and 2016 respectively, have resulted in significant archaeological advances over the last fifteen years. As a follow-up to papers presented at the CAA’s 2017 annual meeting, this session brings together a range of archaeologists, researchers, community members and museum professionals to give an overview of recent advances in the study of an expedition that has captured the public’s interest and imagination for 180 years.

Presentations
Artifacts from HMS Erebus: Excavating Context and Meaning ( Charles Dagneau )
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Charles Dagneau - Parks Canada - Underwater Archaeology Team

The archaeological study and excavation of the HMS Erebus wreck site between 2014 and 2024 produced a significant collection of artifacts, most of which originated from well-defined and sealed archaeological contexts on the lower deck. This paper looks at the methodology used for the underwater excavation and on-site artifact management, including innovative approaches developed for this project in the Canadian Arctic. This presentation also addresses the potential for understanding and interpreting artifact assemblages from different functional spaces aboard Erebus, including the presumed Second and Third Lieutenant’s cabins, presumed Captain’s Steward’s pantry, and a seamen’s chest in the forecastle. Knowledge pertaining to these spaces, and the specific individuals they may relate to, may be valuable for answering some of the fundamental questions related to the 1845 Franklin Expedition

Biodeterioration Beneath the Ice: Investigating wood preservation on HMS Erebus ( Anne Marie Eriksen )
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Anne Marie Eriksen - National Museum of Denmark
  • Oliver  Müller - University of Bergen
  • Nanna Rosenfeldt Lauridsen - National Museum of Denmark
  • David Gregory - National Museum of Denmark

Recent archaeological work on the wreck of HMS Erebus has opened new avenues for understanding biological and environmental processes affecting wooden materials on Arctic shipwrecks. This paper presents a multidisciplinary study conducted in partnership with Parks Canada that integrates experimentally deployed pine blocks and archaeological wood from the wreck with molecular, physical, and imaging-based analyses to characterise wood degradation across the Erebus site.

As part of a controlled field experiment, modern pine blocks were deployed for one year providing a baseline for assessing decay through visual assessment of structural damage, microbial DNA profiling, weight-loss measurements, and X-ray imaging to detect internal damage, including potential shipworm activity. Complementary analyses target archaeological wood from Erebus, including structural timbers, interior fittings, and wooden artefacts preserved in contrasting microenvironments—buried in sediment or exposed in the water column.

The combined dataset enables comparison of degradation pathways across site microenvironments and assessment of how microbial communities, wood anatomy, and environmental variability shape preservation.

By integrating controlled in situ exposure with laboratory-based molecular and materials-science analyses, this project demonstrates the value of a multi-proxy approach for advancing understanding of wood decay and preservation on Erebus, contributing new perspectives to archaeological research on the Franklin expedition.

Coastal Engineering Approaches to Understanding Environmental Impacts to Submerged Archaeological Sites – HMS Erebus and HMS Terror ( Darren Kipping )
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Darren Kipping - Stantec Consulting Ltd.

In their submerged setting, Her Majesty’s Ship (HMS) Erebus and HMS Terror remain exposed to hydrodynamic forces generated by tides and wind-driven storms, posing risks to their structural stability and long-term preservation. These risks are expected to increase as climate change alters Arctic environmental conditions, including the frequency and intensity of extreme weather events.

To assess these threats, Nunami Stantec Limited was retained by the Parks Canada Underwater Archaeology Team to evaluate wind, wave, and water-level exposure at the wreck sites using numerical modeling of publicly available environmental data and anecdotal field observations for validation. A significant storm event from September 2015 was simulated to characterize storm‑driven currents, wave orbital velocities, and near‑bed forcing at wreck depth. Climate change scenarios incorporating projected relative sea level rise were also incorporated into the numerical modeling to assess potential impacts of future storm events which may increase hydrodynamic forcing. The findings improve understanding of hydrodynamic physical hazards affecting HMS Erebus and HMS Terror and assist informing ongoing scientific observations and investigations at both sites.

Examining Site Changes at the Wreck of HMS Erebus via 3D Digital Comparative Analysis ( Brandy Lockhart )
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Brandy Lockhart - Parks Canada

This paper discusses structural changes seen on the wreck of HMS Erebus between 2014 and 2024 as determined through the comparative analysis of digital data collected via photogrammetry and multi-beam echosounder. Comparative analysis was completed using Cloud Compare and Bentley Open Cities Map Ultimate software which allowed for overall change detection analysis of multiple point cloud models of the wreck from different years, as well as the comparison of thin sections of different models through multiple planes, providing quantitative data on variation between years. This analysis allowed for a better understanding of both overall and subtle changes in the site due to environmental factors and archaeological excavation.

Excavating data sources to understand the health of the Franklin expedition, 1845 to 1848 ( Keith Millar )
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Keith Millar - University of Glasgow College of Medical, Veterinary & Life Sciences
  • Adrian Bowman - University of Glasgow School of Mathematics & Statistics

Health factors have long been suspected in the loss of the Franklin expedition but documentary evidence from the expedition is scant.  A sole informative record described the expedition as “All Well” in May 1847, although ice-bound since September 1846.  But by the time the ships were deserted in April 1848, unexplained mortality had occurred which disproportionately affected officers.  Now, Inuit testimony and data from the crews’ remains and medical logs of other expeditions allow historical, forensic and statistical investigations of the cause and timeline of morbidity from departure in May 1845 to spring 1848.  A current focus is nutritional deficiencies which gradually affected Naval provisions to cause scurvy and cardiomyopathy whose debilitating effects worsened when rations lacked sufficient calories to sustain hard physical exertion.  Other Arctic expeditions could mitigate the risk by hunting fresh game, but the Franklin crews’ ice-bound isolation impeded hunting so that debility and mortality increased over winter 1847/48, and after deserting the ships.  Other theories including lead poisoning, botulism and trichinosis are not supported by evidence including X-ray imaging of remains, statistical modelling and contemporary records.  Nutritional deficiencies plausibly explain the loss of the Franklin expedition, but the disproportionate deaths of officers remain unexplained.

From Admiralty Plans to Arctic Seabed: Reconciling Design, Fitting, and Modification Aboard HMS Terror (1845) ( Matthew Betts )
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Matthew Betts - Independent Researcher
  • Ryan Harris - Parks Canada - Underwater Archaeology Team
  • Carol Pillar - Parks Canada - Underwater Archaeology Team
  • Charles Dagneau - Parks Canada - Underwater Archaeology Team

This paper presents the first systematic comparison between the historically reconstructed “as designed” 1845 configuration of HMS Terror and its wreck in Terror Bay, Nunavut, investigated by Parks Canada’s Underwater Archaeology Team from 2016 to 2024.

The historical reconstruction draws on Admiralty plans, official and private correspondence, patent documentation, naval gazettes, newspaper accounts, expedition narratives, and scientific compendia. These sources were synthesized to create detailed plans of the ship’s upper and lower decks as configured at the commencement of the Franklin Expedition in 1845.

These reconstructions are juxtaposed with archaeological plans derived from diving observations, sketches, sonar, high-resolution photography, and video, yielding interpretive plans of the decks and fittings.

Enabled by the wreck’s near-pristine condition and minimal post-sinking disturbance, the comparison reveals undocumented modifications absent from known historical records. Some alterations likely occurred during final dockside preparations, while others suggest adaptive changes made during the expedition.

By integrating these historical and archaeological datasets, the study provides fresh insights into vessel performance, shipboard life, and operational decisions during a nineteenth-century Arctic exploration. It illustrates how Admiralty designs were adapted through dockyard practices and Arctic exigencies, underscoring the value of combining archival reconstruction with underwater archaeology for interpreting well-preserved naval vessels.

Making Space for Cultural Continuity: The Expansion of the Nattilik Heritage Centre brings the 1845 Franklin Expedition into dialogue with local communities ( Sarah Beam-Borg )
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Sarah Beam-Borg - Origin Studios Inc.
  • Jennifer  Ullulaq - Nattilik Heritage Centre
  • Campbell Cameron - Four Peaks Consulting

Knowledge shared by Natchilik Inuit, past and present, from the Kitikmeot Region was essential to locating the wreck sites of HMS Erebus and Terror. Shortly thereafter, the Wrecks of HMS Erebus and HMS Terror National Historic Site of Canada Inuit Impact and Benefit Agreement was signed outlining the importance of co-management, monitoring, and partnership between Parks Canada and Inuit of the region. 

This cooperation led to the expansion of the Nattilik Heritage Centre. Opened June 2025, it houses offices, multipurpose community spaces, a studio for oral histories, a makerspace, and storage for belongings and artifacts. Further, it was determined that selected artifacts excavated from the shipwrecks would be displayed in a purpose-built NHC exhibition where oral histories of local Inuit share how explorers affected traditional ways of life. "Unlocking the Ice” showcases artifacts from the shipwrecks alongside historic and contemporary Inuit belongings with a narrative that centers Natchilik knowledge. 

Jennifer Ullulaq, Campbell Cameron, and Sarah Beam-Borg will outline how collaboration with NHC staff and engagement with local Community guided this project and harnessed the power of co-creation built on trust and passion. A dynamic hub for cultural heritage, the NHC serves as a powerful model for shared stewardship throughout the region.

Reassessing the State of Franklin Expedition Primary Research. ( Alison Freebairn )
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Alison Freebairn
  • Logan Zachary

The 1845 Franklin Expedition carries the public perception of attracting obsessives, meticulously poring over every clue from the past.  This paper argues that such activity has largely revolved around the reading and re-reading of secondary sources, while swaths of primary sources and physical evidence go neglected.  Repeating the popular narrative of obsession – from television documentaries to academic commentary – has attracted more attention than the underlying evidence itself, leaving outright basic work undone even today.  The original focus of trying to rescue survivors, and the continuing focus of trying to explain their demise, further sidelines any material appearing irrelevant to those pursuits.  Examples are presented, detailing fundamental observations on Franklin Expedition relics that might have been made in the 19th century, but that went unremarked until the 21st century.  As Canada and Nunavut have renewed archaeological fieldwork on the Franklin Expedition, fresh reassessments are warranted for any and all evidence collected from before the archaeologists arrived.

Ten Years of Underwater Archaeology at the Wreck of HMS Erebus ( Jonathan Moore )
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Jonathan Moore - Parks Canada

Between 2014 and 2024 Parks Canada’s Underwater Archaeology Team and its partners completed ten underwater archaeological field projects at the wreck of HMS Erebus. Collectively this comprised both open-water and through-ice operations, almost 700 dives, detailed 3D site recording, excavation, material culture research and site environment studies among other efforts. This paper will give a summary of the fieldwork and research completed on this iconic wreck and the progression of logistics, methods and multi-disciplinary work over ten years of study. It will also discuss the main research questions that guided the project and summarize what was learned through this archaeological investigation. Further, it will set-up other papers within this session, point to technical innovations, and outline our longstanding collaboration with Inuit partners.

The Care and Keeping of a Cold Case: The Conservation of Marine Archaeological Artifacts from HMS Erebus ( Kristen Stockstil )
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Kristen Stockstil - Parks Canada

Since 2015, the Parks Canada Archaeological Conservation team has undertaken the complex task of preserving approximately 1500 artifacts recovered from HMS Erebus from Sir John Franklin’s ill‑fated 1845–1848 Arctic expedition.

Marine archaeological objects have unique preservation challenges and, in turn, require unique stabilization methods compared to artifacts excavated from dry, terrestrial environments. The sheer variety of material-type, size and degradation states of these objects ensure that never a dull moment is had in the Conservation lab. 

This presentation examines the conservation processes and reasoning employed by Parks Canada artifact conservators through a series of representative artifact case studies. It highlights the scientific, ethical, and practical considerations guiding treatment choices, and examines the broader role that artifact conservators play in the long‑term stewardship, interpretation, and accessibility of historic artifacts recovered from HMS Erebus.

The last days of the Franklin expedition: is the absence of evidence finally becoming evidence of absence? ( Robert Park )
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Robert Park - University of Waterloo

On April 25, 1848, at a bleak spot on the northwest coast of King William Island, Captain Francis Crozier penned just eight words outlining his plan for the 105 sailors he commanded who, three days before, had deserted their ships: “start on tomorrow 26th for Backs Fish River”. Almost everything known about what the 105 actually did immediately before and after he wrote those words comes from archaeological evidence: material remains deposited or created by those sailors, including their own bodies, complemented only by some vital Inuit observations deriving from brief encounters with some of the survivors on the south coast of the island. Over the past 17 decades archaeological evidence has slowly been documented by many Inuit, by a long series of Euro-American searchers who travelled to this region, and by a very few professional archaeologists. Over those decades a much larger body of interpretations and hypotheses has also accumulated, at a pace far faster than the accumulation of actual archaeological evidence. This paper will seek to review on a broad scale some of the interpretations and hypotheses that have been proposed in light of what that accumulated archaeological evidence shows, and especially what it does not show.

“We have caused a great variety of valuable instruments to be put on board the ships”: Science on the 1845 Franklin Expedition ( John Ratcliffe )
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • John Ratcliffe - Underwater Archaeology Team, Parks Canada

The focus of the 1845 Franklin expedition is often remembered as primarily geographic, to complete the last link in a Northwest Passage, but the Admiralty’s instructions to Franklin emphasized the importance of the expedition’s scientific mandate and noted that “We have caused a great variety of valuable instruments to be put on board the ships.” This scientific focus is reflected in the archaeology and material culture of Erebus and Terror, where artifacts related to terrestrial magnetism, natural history, meteorology, navigation and cartography, and photography have been observed and recovered since the wrecks were located in 2014 and 2016. Many of these “valuable instruments” defy easy identification as they are incomplete or found in secondary contexts, a challenge compounded by the sheer number and diversity of instruments known or presumed to have been carried aboard the vessels. Archaeological and historical research has resulted in the identification of several previously unidentified objects, however, illustrating the expedition’s wide scope of scientific inquiry, and hinting at further stories which remain obscure.