Commemorating Indian Residential Schools through Archaeology and Digital Heritage

Date/Time: 
Friday, May 7, 2021 - 2:20pm to 5:00pm
(CST)
Room: 
3
Organizer(s): 
  • Peter Dawson, University of Calgary
  • Madisen Hvidberg, University of Calgary
Contact Email: 
Session Description (300 word max): 

Indian Residential Schools (IRS) were part of an education system, in name only, that caused great pain and suffering to generations of Indigenous people across Canada for over a hundred years. The few schools that remain standing, the grounds where they once stood, as well as the cemeteries and unmarked graves of missing children, exist as “sites of conscience” and “witnesses to history”. Consequently, establishing a national strategy for understanding the historical and ongoing traumas of the IRS system and commemorating these spaces is among the Calls to Action issued by the Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada (TRC). This session explores how community-guided projects across the country are using archaeology, remote sensing, digital heritage, and other approaches to ensure that the histories, legacies, and effects of Indian Residential Schools in Canada are not ignored or forgotten.     

Presentations
02:20 PM: Digitally Preserving Former Indian Residential Schools: Two Case Studies from Alberta
Presentation format:
Author(s):
  • Peter  Dawson - University of Calgary
  • Madisen Hvidberg - University of Calgary
  • Katayoon Etemad - University of Calgary
  • Faramarz  Samavati - University of Calgary
  • Derek Lichti - University of Calgary
  • Kate Pexman - University of Calgary
  • Vivian Ayoungman - Old Sun College
  • Sherri Chisan - University nuhelot’įne thaiyots’į nistameyimâkanak Blue Quills

Surviving Indian residential school (IRS) buildings are among the most poignant reminders of the history and legacy of the residential school era in Canada. While over a hundred schools operated during this period, only a small number remain standing. Among the Calls to Action defined by the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) are several that deal specifically with the issue of preserving and commemorating former residential school sites. In this paper we discuss two community-guided projects which use 3D laser scanning to digitally preserve two surviving Indian residential school buildings in Alberta. We outline how these projects can build capacity in participating communities via the training of Indigenous youth in digital technologies. We also discuss how the virtual and physical models of surviving school buildings generated by our project are being used to create “as built” architectural plans, online exhibits, and educational materials which will help increase awareness of the history and legacy of these schools, as well as honor residential school survivors, families, and communities. 

02:30 PM: "Documenting" Digital Documentation at Old Sun Community College
Presentation format:
Author(s):
  • Madisen Hvidberg - University of Calgary
  • Joey Big Snake
  • Meagan Breaker
  • Brendon Many Bears
  • Peter Dawson - University of Calgary

Strength-based approaches emphasize recognizing strengths of individuals derived by their unique experiences and backgrounds. Approaching community projects with the flexibility to apply strength-based approaches can allow for collaboration beyond the scope of original research design. During the 3D digital documentation and preservation of Old Sun Community College in the summer of 2020, three Siksika students were hired to participate and be trained in terrestrial laser scanning (TLS) and survey techniques. However, in working together the students’ art-based backgrounds and interests in more traditional audio-visual recording methods led to the development of a documentary-based project to capture the process of 3D preservation at the school. Driven by the students’ own interests, passions, and skillsets, this presentation discusses the experiences and benefits of the application of a strength-based model for this on-site collaboration.

02:40 PM: Addressing the Missing Children: Implementing the Truth and Reconciliation Commission Calls to Action 72 to 76 on School Deaths and Unmarked Burial Information
Presentation format:
Author(s):
  • Alex Maass - Crown-Indigenous Relations and Northern Affairs

Known as the Missing Children Calls to Action, 72 through 76, are five of the 94 Calls to Action issued by the Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada in its 2015 Final Report. An estimated 6000 children died at the 140 schools in the system country wide over the course of the latter part of the 1800s and the first half of the 1900s. The TRC Commissioners called on the federal government to work with Indigenous communities, families, and partners to develop a national approach for the ongoing identification, maintenance, commemoration, and protection of these burial sites. This presentation will provide an overview of recent work at Crown-Indigenous Relations and Northern Affairs Canada (CIRNAC) to advance this suite of Calls to Action in collaboration with Indigenous communities, to address the deaths of children at Canada’s Residential Schools and to discuss ongoing work to locate and document their largely unmarked places of burial.

02:50 PM: The Nepowewin Mission Cemetery: A Community-led, Academic and Corporate Partnership to Locate Unmarked Graves
Presentation format:
Author(s):
  • Terence Clark - University of Saskatchewan
  • Dave Rondeau - Métis Nation of Saskatchewan
  • Butch Amundson - Stantec
  • Glenn Stuart - University of Saskatchewan
  • Olenka Kawchuk - University of Saskatchewan
  • James Hulsebosch - Stantec
  • Joshua Murphy
  • Kali Sielsky
  • Angela Burant

A Métis-led project to determine the location of unmarked graves at the historic mission site of Nepowewin brought together archaeologists from the University of Saskatchewan, Stantec, and the Métis Nation of Saskatchewan. Nepowewin (or the Budd Mission) was established by Henry Budd in 1852 and operated until at least 1875. Mission records indicate at least 26 individuals were in interned in the cemetery. The location of the cemetery and graves has since been lost. The Nepowewin Project leveraged the skills, knowledge, and technologies of academics, consultants, and community members in a novel approach that aimed to locate graves in a thorough, efficient, and culturally sensitive manner. This model may prove beneficial for the Indian Residential School Unmarked Graves project.

03:10 PM: Finding the Relatives: Wise Practices for Research Design in Locating Unmarked Graves in Western Canada
Presentation format:
Author(s):
  • Kisha Supernant - Institute of Prairie and Indigenous Archaeology, University of Alberta
  • William Wadsworth - Institute of Prairie and Indigenous Archaeology, University of Alberta
  • Terence Clark - Department of Anthropology and Archaeology, University of Saskatchewan

Many Indigenous communities across the lands we call Canada have buried their ancestors since time immemorial, but the impacts of colonization on burial practices, places, and histories has led to Indigenous communities not always knowing where their ancestors and relatives are buried. Over the past several years, we  have been approached by multiple Indigenous communities in Alberta and Saskatchewan to assist in locating the missing burial places of the ancestors using archaeological remote sensing techniques. Some of the requests have been to help locate missing children around residential schools, but the majority of the requests have been to assist communities in surveying local historic cemeteries and other burial contexts. From these projects, we have been able to refine archaeological remote sensing techniques in a variety of environments with different burial types and different community histories. In this paper, we share what we have learned about wise practices of research design, both in the technical aspects of the application of archaeological remote sensing, as well as building good relationships between archaeologists and community members.

03:20 PM: Bearing witness: What good work can archaeology do in an Indian Residential School context?
Presentation format:
Author(s):
  • Eric Simons - UBC
  • Andrew Martindale - UBC
  • Alison Wylie - UBC

The Kuper Island Industrial School operated for 85 years (1890-1975) on Penelakut traditional territory. It is known as a place of significant abuse of Indigenous children—physical, emotional, cultural, and spiritual. The Truth and Reconciliation’s National Student Memorial Register records the names of 121 children who died while in the school’s care, but there are few records of where they were buried. Many in the community are concerned that ‘lost’ children lie in unmarked and clandestine graves on the former school grounds, which are at the heart of the present-day Penelakut village. Not knowing where these unmarked burials are located continues to be a matter of serious concern for those who are committed to fostering a healthy, safe, and independent community. We explore our role as researchers in the context of an emerging partnership with the Penelakut Tribe, one aim of which is to locate the burials of the missing children. This relationship is in the process of taking shape, so we focus on understanding conditions for developing trust, and the interactional expertise necessary to work well together, with a good heart. We suggest that, in some respects, this may usefully be understood as a practice of witnessing on several dimensions.

03:30 PM: Heeding Calls to Action 71–76
Presentation format:
Author(s):
  • Eldon Yellowhorn - Department of Indigenous Studies, Simon Fraser University, Burnaby, BC

Among the Calls to Action issued by the Truth and Reconciliation Commission in its Final Report in 2015, numbers 71–76 specifically address archaeology. Together they identify the way that the profession can mobilize its knowledge, expertise and resources to advance this effort. Setting right this injustice means that archaeologists have a unique perspective to offer to the national dialogue about reconciliation. Using archaeological methods and field work we will define our contribution to this conversation. However, embedded in the broad goals are some very personal stories of unresolved loss. We can also help bring resolution to these cases.

03:40 PM: Quantifying Uncertainty in Ground Penetrating Radar
Presentation format:
Author(s):
  • Andrew Martindale - UBC
  • William  Wadsworth - Alberta
  • Colin Grier - WSU

Ground Penetrating Radar (GPR) is becoming a trusted method for non-destructive mapping of near-surface buried features. Mapping of historic cemeteries and subsurface stone architecture is now routine. However, GPR tends to be used where it works and abandoned otherwise, and in all contexts the quantification of uncertainty in signal identification is unclear. This approach favours contexts where anomalies appear as high-contrast signals against a homogeneous background, usually with spatial characteristics that unambiguously match expectations. However, when background heterogeneity is high, the GPR signal patterning is noisy, and the spatial patterning of targets and arrangements is unclear, some evaluation of uncertainty is necessary. We identify two avenues to improve the quantification of confidence: an explicit assessment of the visual elements within GPR projections and the application of statistics to the 3D data cube represented by gridded traces. The first of these is a more systematic application of judgmental evaluations that can be compiled and combined with non-GPR data into an index of confidence. The second is an as-yet untested effort to define the difference in content, boundaries, and reflective effects of the propagated EM signal in numerical terms, thereby allowing for a computation of uncertainty between field data and hypothesized patterns.

04:00 PM: Negotiating Multiple Authorities in a National Gravesite Register
Presentation format:
Author(s):
  • Raymond  Frogner - National Center for Truth and Reconciliation
  • Ingrid Reiche - University of Calgary

Many factors must be considered when developing a keeping place for survivors’ memories of unmarked gravesites produced by residential school operations. These include unresolved questions related to concepts of legal and cultural authority over lands containing unmarked residential school grave sites. For example, land claims are an ongoing issue in the Indigenous/settler relationship. The misuse of public lands for Indigenous childrens’ graves creates understandably more distrust in an ongoing colonial narrative of settler dispossession of Indigenous lands than almost any other issue. Other issues focus on jurisdictional control over unmarked grave sites, the need to identify and consult with cultural authorities, and data sovereignty over the conditions of access, use, and ceremony for information relating to these sensitive heritage sites. This presentation will consider these issues in the context of a national repository for residential school gravesite information.

04:10 PM: Circles of Healing Honoring Elders, Spirits and Land
Presentation format:
Author(s):
  • Steeves Paulette - Algoma University
  • Krista McCraken - Algoma University

Every day as I walk across the land I remember the generations of Anishnaabe children who were forced to attend residential school here. My footsteps follow the spirits of Anishnaabe youth who walked these hallways before me. Some of them never left, they are buried in the graveyard, in the quiet forest behind Shingwauk Hall, just past the crying rock. How do we honor their memory and Anishnaabe Elders and communities? How do we teach the next generation about this violent history of colonization? Education about the past and honoring in the present take many forms. Travelling in sacred circles of healing from the past to the present led by Anishnaabe elders and Survivors of Shingwauk Residential School.The history of the Shingwauk site is displayed through photographs and memories hung silently along pale blue walls. Truth telling lines the shelves of the Shingwauk Residential Schools Centre archives. Memories, stories and history are shared with the world through digital archives, digitized archival materials, and virtual tours as a starting place for healing and honoring.

04:20 PM: Shaping the Legacy Program at the Mi’kmawey Debert Cultural Center
Presentation format:
Author(s):
  • Tim Bernard - Mi’kmawey Debert Cultural Centre
  • Dorene Bernard - Mi’kmawey Debert Cultural Centre

Multiple engagement sessions in 2013/14 and in 2018-2021 has clearly charted a path to honour Survivors and their descendant families at the Future Cultural Centre scheduled to open in 2025. They have also provided guidance and direction on pursuing National Historic Site Designation, Research on the site for burials and a historic graveyard, Commemoration for Survivors and Decedents. In partnership with the Tripartite Forum’s Culture and Heritage working committee, Parks Canada and the NS Department of Communities, Culture and Heritage, Boreas Heritage was engaged to conduct  a GPR investigation, provide high resolution imagery and conduct a unmanned Aerial Vehicle Survey. Our research continues this spring and summer. The IRS Legacy Project is committed to be part of the vision for the Mi’kmawey Debert Cultural Centre, where we continue to Share our Stories, Protect of Past and explore our History.

04:30 PM: Working for Sioux Valley Dakota Nation: Finding missing Indigenous children to foster restorative justice, repatriation, and reconciliation through forensic anthropology and archaeology at the Brandon Residential School
Presentation format:
Author(s):
  • Katherine Nichols - Simon Fraser University
  • Darian  Kennedy - Community Liaison for the Sioux Valley Dakota Nation + Simon Fraser University
  • Emily Holland - Brandon University
  • Deanna Reder - Simon Fraser University
  • John  Albanese - University of Windsor
  • Dongya Yang,  Yang - Simon Fraser University
  • Kim  Figura - Simon Fraser University
  • Dayle  Blackbird - Brandon University + Simon Fraser University
  • Hugo  Cardoso - Simon Fraser University
  • Eldon  Yellowhorn - Simon Fraser University

Calls to Action 74 & 75 in the final report of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission reaffirms the importance of locating and identifying graves and cemeteries of Indian Residential Schools. However, it is silent on the ambit of legal responsibility and formal accountability held by federal and provincial agencies. Nor do academic researchers and community partners have clear guidelines for developing community engagement and partnerships of this kind. This project is being spearheaded by Sioux Valley Dakota Nation and supported by partners at universities in British Columbia, Ontario and Manitoba. Currently, we are working to identify affected communities with children that may be buried in the Brandon Indian Residential School cemeteries. By working collaboratively to establish a path forward, we aim to restore dignity and honour to these children and their gravesites, in the ways and desires of their communities. This presentation discusses the projects’ initial steps to ensure Sioux Valley Dakota Nation and affected Indigenous Nations are involved in all aspects of the research. We demonstrate that university-based researchers, graduate and undergraduate students collaborating with Indigenous Nations can lead to progress on addressing social justice issues and human rights violations.