From Prairies to Parkland: New Collaborations, Data, and Interpretations

Session Hosting Format: 
in-person session
Date/Time: 
Friday, May 3, 2024 - 8:20am to 4:00pm
(CST)
Room: 
Michelangelo C
Organizer(s): 
  • Robert Losey, Department of Anthropology, University of Alberta
Contact Email: 
Session Description (300 word max): 

Indigenous peoples of the Canadian prairies and parklands have remarkably diverse long-term histories. Archaeological efforts to understand these histories have been reinvigorated through a variety of new collaborations, methodological advances, and increasingly larger datasets. Community-based archaeology, sourcing studies, residue analyses, zooarchaeology, radiocarbon dating, and a suite of other approaches all have contributed to these developments. This session explores these efforts and approaches through a series of papers spanning the Canadian prairie provinces. Contributions addressing topics spanning from the Early Holocene through to the colonial period will be provided.

Presentations
08:20 AM to 08:40 AM: Ageing archaeological dog and wolf remains on the Canadian Plains
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Megan Bieraugle - University of Alberta
  • Robert Losey - University of Alberta
  • Lei Ding - University of Alberta

Relationships between Indigenous people, dogs, and wolves are complex and have a long history on the Canadian Plains. Understanding canid age at death could shed important light on these relationships, including how people cared for their dogs or interacted with wild wolves encountered at kill sites. Existing canid ageing methods are subjective, rely on teeth not commonly recovered, and have undocumented margins of error. This study uses known age modern wolves from Alberta, Yellowstone National Park, and the Northwest Territories to examine how tooth wear rates correlate with age. Wolves from these regions are used because they should have far less dietary variation than past dogs, meaning that the relationship between age and wear should be less convoluted. Dog tooth wear is likely to be far more complicated due to their variable dietary dependence on people but also their self-provisioning through hunting and scavenging. Our results show that tooth wear has a positive but poor correlation to age, and that statistically significant differences in wear rates occur between each wolf population. Further research is required to fully understand the nuances of canid tooth wear and its relationships to age, diet, trauma, and a suite of other factors.

08:40 AM to 09:00 AM: Tackling the Enigma of Late Precontact Southwest Manitoba: Insights from the Pierson Wildlife Management Area Archaeological Project and Beyond
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Mary E Malainey - Anthropology-Brandon University and Manitoba Archaeological Society

Five years of archaeological research south of Melita by Brandon University and the Manitoba Archaeological Society have provided a greater understanding of the complex pre-European contact past of this region. Prompted by the discovery of two complete bison scapula hoes in 2018, excavations indicate that an intense occupation of the area by Indigenous horticulturalists began in the late 1400s or early 1500s CE. Evidence of an earlier occupation along Gainsborough Creek includes Besant/Sonota points, features, earthworks, and radiocarbon age estimates. Early Woodland (Adena, Kramer and Waubseau) points have been found nearby and at sites to the north. The timing of these occupations coincides with the two distinct use episodes of pipestone reported elsewhere, the first approximately 2000 years ago and the second beginning in the 14th century CE. The presence of worked red dolomite and availability of raw material along Pipestone Creek may in part explain the concentration of habitation sites and earthworks in the southwest corner of Manitoba. A similar re-occupation and re-use of previously constructed burial mounds by later horticulturalists was reported in the Lockport area along the Red River north of Winnipeg. These results lend additional support for a re-consideration of the Devils Lake-Sourisford Burial Complex.

09:00 AM to 09:20 AM: The Buried Pot Feature and Preliminary Results of Palaeobotanical Analyses of Artifacts and Soil in and around the Pierson Wildlife Management Area, Southwest Manitoba
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Mary E Malainey - Anthropology-Brandon University and Manitoba Archaeological Society
  • Sara Halwas - Sessional lecturer, Department of Anthropology, University of Manitoba
  • Clarence Surette - Department of Anthropology, Lakehead University
  • Matt Boyd - Department of Anthropology, Lakehead University

Evidence of pre-European contact Indigenous farming activities has been recovered from sites in and around the Gainsborough Creek valley in the southwest corner of Manitoba. Fragments of an intentionally buried pot were recovered near a hearth at site DgMg-168, on the adjacent prairie. The significance of this vessel, which dates to the beginning of the horticultural occupation, is considered. Recent results from the palaeobotanical analysis of associated carbonized vessel residues and soil core samples from the Olson site (DgMg-167) on the valley floor will be presented. This information, combined with distribution of sites, features and artifacts in and around the Pierson Wildlife Management Area, is providing a more complete understanding of how Late Precontact Indigenous farmers used the area.

09:20 AM to 09:40 AM: Revisiting Archaeological Understandings of Métis Identity Using Foodways
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Solène Mallet Gauthier - University of Alberta

The archaeology of the Métis, a post-contact Indigenous people whose homeland encompasses much of western Canada and parts of the northwestern United States, has not received the same amount of attention from archaeologists as the histories of other Indigenous groups. While a few papers have been published throughout the 1970s to the 2000s, it can generally be said that the research done on Métis archaeological sites and materials has remained very sparse until the creation of the EMITA (Exploring Métis Identity Through Archaeology) project, led by Dr. Kisha Supernant. As part of this project, research undertaken by graduate students have all either involved re-examining previous interpretations and understandings of Métis material culture, or included the use of methods never used before in such contexts. Using the example of work currently being done on materials collected at Chimney Coulee (DjOe-6), this presentation will focus on the application of methods from environmental archaeology and the concept of foodways to revisit traditional archaeological understandings of Métis identity.

09:40 AM to 10:00 AM: Infrequency as a Measure of Importance: Pottery Use and Maize Consumption by Mobile Hunter-Gatherers of the Northern Great Plains (2000 to 1150 BP)
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Andrew Lints

What we now label Besant and Sonota material culture originates from a time and places where ‘new’ activities and technologies appeared in northern Great Plains settings. The use of pottery marked an alternative to culinary practices that previously required the heating of stones to boil foods. Recent examination of these vessels allowed for the opportunity to address how ‘new’ materials and foods were adopted. Analyses of pottery from 24 sites across the northern Great Plains, revealed how infrequent pottery was within the overall material culture during this time. Likewise, microbotanical evidence of maize (Zea mays spp. mays) was limited to only pottery vessels from the Stelzer (39DW242) and Arpan Mound (39DW252) sites, in northern South Dakota. While these numbers may seem anomalous, the context of the Stelzer and Arpan Mound sites suggests otherwise. The Stelzer and Arpan mound sites represent two locations where significant multi-community gatherings occurred. Although both items were rare within the material culture of this time, pottery and maize were central to the ritual activities conducted at these sites. Further, the use of pottery and maize may have been reserved for significant events.

10:20 AM to 10:40 AM: The Excavation of a Stone Cairn Cache in Southern Saskatchewan
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Eliann Guinan
  • Mike Markowski - AtlHeritage Services Corp.

In 2018, a stone cairn was discovered on a prominent hilltop in the Missouri Coteau in southern Saskatchewan, not an uncommon discovery. Due to potential impacts from development, a salvage excavation commenced which included the excavation of the entire stone cairn structure and additional subsurface testing in the immediate area. A preliminary interpretation for the stone cairn was its functional use as a navigational marker; however, the initial interpretation was retracted upon the discovery of a cache cavity within the unexpectedly large structure of the stone cairn. Had the excavation not occurred, the stone cairn may have been misinterpreted; this is a common issue at stone cairn sites across the northern Plains.

10:40 AM to 11:00 AM: What’s that doing there!?: 2022 Excavations at GfOx-59 and GfOx-61 in Sir Winston Churchill Provincial Park.
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Taylor Graham - Bison Historical Servioces Ltd.

In the fall of 2022, on behalf of Alberta Parks, a Historical Resources Impact Mitigation of two archaeological sites (GfOx-59 and GfOx-61) was conducted on the Big Island of Sir Winston Churchill Provincial Park in Lac La Biche Alberta.  These sites contained two different ceramic assemblages, with GfOx-59 producing Narrows Fabric Impressed Ware, first identified in the Buffalo Narrows region of Northwestern Saskatchewan, and the ceramic ware most common in the region.  While GfOx-61 produced Avery Horizontal Corded Ware, first identified in southeastern Manitoba, and never before observed in northeastern Alberta.  Both wares are discussed and their distributions across western Canada examined.  It is posited that with the newly confirmed presence of Avery Corded ware within northeastern Alberta, past ceramic sherd identifications may have combined the relatively similar morphology of body sherds due to a superficial or untrained inspection, and that some previously collected assemblages could potentially contain unrecognized Avery Horizontal Corded Ware.  If confirmed the presence of this ware across the region could then indicate a previously undiscovered cultural expression in the region, or a long distance trade and influence network stretching from southeastern Manitoba to northeastern Alberta.

11:00 AM to 11:20 AM: Location, Location, and Location: The role of Sand Dunes in Intensive Bison Hunting on the Northern Plains
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Tim Panas - Museums Association of Saskatchewan

In examining the roles that ecology and landscape have played in Northern Plains bison behaviour and subsequent human settlement patterns, one region that has not been fully recognized is sand dunes. Far from being anomalous features within the larger prairie grasslands, dunes are readily found within the region. Further, while commonly perceived as being desolate landscapes, the unique physical properties of sand dunes have allowed them to act as vital resource areas that were extensively exploited by both Indigenous and Settler populations over the past 2,000 years. This paper will examine, through the archaeological, ethnographic, and documentary/oral histories of the region, how dunes played a key role in bison acquisition activities that fuelled not only the industrialization of pounding activities during the Besant period, but also the spatial organization of Fur Trade centres during the 18th and 19th Century.

11:20 AM to 11:40 AM: Stone Circles Revisited: Comparing Archaeological Assumptions with Blackfoot Practice
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Lindsay Amundsen-Meyer - Department of Anthropology and Archaeology, University of Calgary
  • Kent Ayoungman - Independent Scholar, Siksika First Nation

While scholars have continued to debate the research value of excavating stone circles, few have questioned the assumptions we use to interpret them. This despite the fact these assumptions originate in or before the era of Processual archaeology and were likely formed without input from descendant communities. Yet, pick up an archaeological report detailing a survey of stone feature sites and you will almost certainly see reference to whether each circle is a double or single ring of stones (the former assumed to result from cold season occupation, the latter from warm season occupation), whether there are any gaps (particularly to the east) consistent with a door, and whether or not any cobbles representative of an interior hearth are present. This paper will demonstrate that these assumptions are overly simplistic, and that any interpretation of archaeological sites based on them is fundamentally flawed. It is time that Plains archaeologists work with descendant communities such as the Blackfoot to understand from a culturally specific perspective how tipis are designed and erected and apply these understandings to our interpretation of the archaeological record.

11:40 AM to 12:00 PM: Addressing the Finer Issues with Burned-Rock Feature Analysis on the Northwestern Plains
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Allie Bradford - University of Calgary

Stone features described as burned-rock features (BRF) by archaeologists represent essential practices in the lifeways of past peoples as they served as cooking elements, heated homes, and were used for ceremonial purposes. Yet, meaningful interpretation of BRFs has been limited on the Northwestern Plains due to morphological variability, inconsistent terminology, as well as the perceived lack of interpretive value of fire-broken rock (FBR). This lack of meaningful engagement with BRF has resulted in the misidentification and misinterpretation of BRF, leading individuals to overlook the cultural significance of these features to Plains Indigenous peoples. Therefore, in this discussion, I will address the finer issues associated with BRF analysis. I will include an in-depth review of known BRF in the Northwestern Plains to highlight these issues. Finally, I will emphasize the importance of BRF studies to demonstrate that BRFs present critical data which can be utilized to better understand the lifeways of past peoples.

01:20 PM to 01:40 PM: New Collaborative Efforts Towards A Better Understanding of Lake Midden, a Gathering Place
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Robert Losey - University of Alberta

This presentation provides an introduction to the renewed efforts being made to better understand the Lake Midden (EfNg-1) site near Last Mountain Lake, Saskatchewan. This work is a collaborative effort by members of the University of Alberta, the University of Saskatchewan, and the Touchwood Agency Tribal Council Elders. We are working together to comprehensively examine the massive collections recovered from this Mortlach phase site over its decades-long history of excavation. In the presentation, new radiocarbon dating of the site to better understand its chronology and use as a winter gathering area are outlined. Our initial steps toward developing educational materials for Touchwood Agency communities also are described. Finally, we present potential evidence for the falsification of some artifacts at the site, likely related to attempts made decades ago to increase artifacts’ value when being sold to museums. 

01:40 PM to 02:00 PM: Microbotanical residues of past Indigenous foodways: insights from Lake Midden pot sherds
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Shalen Prado - University of Saskatchewan
  • Hailey Kennedy - University of Saskatchewan

Archaeological investigations of ceramics in Saskatchewan have historically focused on typological analysis – an approach that classifies ceramic artifacts based on observable physical attributes such as shape, decoration, paste type, and temper. However, the application of residue analyses offers novel avenues for testing and refining these typologies by extracting adhering food residues and other substances trapped in ceramic surfaces. Such approaches can enhance our understanding of past function and use of ceramic material culture. This paper presents findings from non-destructive microbotanical sampling of 15 pot sherds from the Lake Midden site (EfNg-1). Through the examination of these results, which include starch grain residues, we delve into pre-contact Indigenous culinary practices in Saskatchewan. This study was conducted in collaboration with the Royal Saskatchewan Museum and with consent from the Touchwood Hills Tribal Council.

02:00 PM to 02:20 PM: The Zooarchaeology of Lake Midden (EfNg-1)
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Faith Boser - University of Alberta

Lake Midden (EfNg-1) is a Morlach phase, Pericolonial period site with occupations ranging from the 16th to 17th centuries. The site is located in a coulee near Last Mountain Lake in southern Saskatchewan. An extensive collection of materials was retrieved from the site through both looting and systematic excavations between the 1940s and the 1990s. The collection includes Mortlach pottery, lithics, trade goods, bone tools, ice-gliders and other modified objects, but most are fragmented faunal remains. Despite the intermittent work on the site over many decades, the faunal collection has not been comprehensively and systematically analyzed. Taxonomic identifications conducted so far indicate that most remains are bison, followed by Canid sp. (wolves, dogs, coyotes, and fox) remains. Smaller amounts of other taxons have been identified, including deer (Odocoileus sp.), mustelids (Mustelidae sp.), bear (Ursus sp.), beaver (Castor canadensis), rabbit (Leporidae sp.), and most surprisingly, horse (Equus sp.). Fetal bison remains are present in the collection, which have been used to determine the seasonality of the site. This paper discusses the ongoing analyses of the Lake Midden faunal remains, including preliminary results.

02:20 PM to 02:40 PM: Saskatchewan Obsidian Project
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Gary Wowchuk - Swan Valley Historical Museum
  • Tim  Allan - Ember Archaeology
  • Cindy  Scheer - Royal Saskatchewan Museum
  • Evelyn  Siegfried - Royal Saskatchewan Museum (Retired)
  • Jack  Trusty - Regina Archaeological Society
  • Nathaniel  Wowchuk - University of Saskatchewan

This paper summarizes the results of geochemical analysis of a large sample of obsidian artifacts from Saskatchewan that are being curated at the Royal Saskatchewan Museum, Saskatchewan Archaeological Society and in private collections. Using pXRF, two hundred obsidian artifacts from fifty-five Saskatchewan archaeological sites and private collections were analyzed with the results indicating that the Obsidian Cliff, Wyoming, and Bear Gulch, Idaho being the most common sources of obsidian found in archaeological sites within Saskatchewan. Glass Buttes, Oregon, Browns Bench, Idaho, and other unknown sources were also detected in a small number of samples. A geochemical match of an artifact to an obsidian source indicates that Indigenous peoples have transported or traded volcanic glass from those sources, a confirmation of widespread trade networks across the continent. While the preliminary results are still being analyzed, this study will give future researchers a comprehensive baseline of data to build upon and use as a reference.

02:40 PM to 03:00 PM: Erosion of History: Confronting the Loss of Archaeological Resources at Lake Diefenbaker
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Jennifer Rychlo - Stantec

The Lake Diefenbaker region of south-central Saskatchewan is an archaeologically significant area of the Northern Plains. It contains over 500 recorded archaeological sites that span the entirety of the Precontact period and range from multicomponent habitation sites to sacred ceremonial sites. The importance of this region to the Precontact Peoples of North America is clear. However, since the establishment of the Lake Diefenbaker reservoir in the 1960s, shoreline erosion and unauthorized artifact collection has significantly harmed these valuable archaeological resources. This presentation will explore the history of Lake Diefenbaker, its impact on the archaeological sites of the region, and discuss strategies to mitigate further damage to these valuable cultural resources. 

03:20 PM to 03:40 PM: Lessons from the Mountains: Five Years of Archaeology, Collaboration, and Public Engagement in Paahtómahksikimi, Waterton Lakes National Park
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Jennifer Ayles - Parks Canada

In 2017 a Wildfire ripped through Waterton Lakes NP, burning ~40% of the park, and heavily impacting irreplaceable archaeological vestiges as well as a living cultural landscape. A team of archaeologists was formed to conduct a 5-year project, seeking to record and research the unprecedented degree of new archaeological finds, and the unparalleled visibility afforded by vegetation and soil removal.

The project has now been complete for a year, and we have been able to look back on all of the lessons learned during our days in the field. Pedestrian surveys, excavations, and sampling have afforded us the opportunity to add to our quantitative knowledge of a regional human history. However, a multi focus approach grounded in teachings beyond strict ‘academic’ confines provided us with infinitely more.

A blending of perspectives saw us diving into archaeology, environmental change, past fire history, engagement with the surrounding indigenous nations, communities, landowners, and interested public, and even a few ponds. Here, we hope to share with you some of the discoveries made, lessons learned, and questions raised by the Post-Kenow Wildfire Archaeology Project.

03:40 PM to 04:00 PM: Phytoliths at Head-Smashed-In Buffalo Jump: Plants as Human Use and Environmental Indicators
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Kali Wade - Atlatl Archaeology Ltd.
  • Shawn Bubel - University of Lethbridge
  • Robert Dawe - Royal Alberta Museum
  • Kevin McGeough - University of Lethbridge
  • Natalia Vanzo Jais - University of Lethbridge
  • Tanner Straat - University of Lethbridge
  • Samantha Kondor - University of Lethbridge, Atlatl Archaeology Ltd.
  • Rachel  Lindemann - Atlatl Archaeology Ltd.

Head-Smashed-In Buffalo Jump is an internationally recognized bison kill site and, in the words of the late Jack Brink, is known as “the mother of all buffalo jumps”. Beginning (at minimum) 6,500 years ago and used until the Contact period, this location provided ideal conditions for the communal hunting of large game. Indigenous ingenuity and knowledge of these animals are showcased at the site. The repeated success of the hunt resulted in an extraordinarily densely packed archaeological site composed of millions of bison bones, amongst other remains. One of the questions that remains is if there were extended gaps in site use during the Altithermal or other periods of climatic decline. Our study addresses this question by examining phytoliths from column samples and employing aridity indices from subfamilies of grasses. We hypothesize that measures of aridity, paired with the absence or presence of water microremains and riparian plants, could provide proxies for paleoenvironmental conditions. This would constitute evidence for environmental fluctuations that occurred at Head-Smashed-In over time. Establishing higher resolution environmental contexts for the stratified cultural remains is important, whether significant climatic changes impacted site use or not.