Being with Animals in the North: Archaeological Perspectives

Date/Time: 
Thursday, May 6, 2021 - 12:00pm to 2:20pm
(CST)
Room: 
3
Organizer(s): 
  • Robert Losey, University of Alberta
  • Tatiana Nomokonova, University of Saskatchewan
Contact Email: 
Session Description (300 word max): 

This session explores relationships between people and animals in the circumpolar North. We welcome papers focusing on any type of archaeological materials, ranging from faunal remains to artwork. We define the North for the session to include any boreal or arctic region. Theoretical, methodological, and overview papers will be included, and we particularly encourage contributions from Indigenous-based perspectives and collaborative research endeavors.   

Presentations
12:00 PM: Domesticating Dogs in the North
Presentation format:
Author(s):
  • Robert Losey - University of Alberta

Anthropology and the biological sciences now both commonly argue that domestication is an on-going process, not an event confined to the far distant past. Very recent research suggests that dogs may have originated in Siberia well into the Pleistocene, and dogs have clearly been living in portions of the Arctic for at least 11,000 years, if not far longer. Domestication did not end with these early appearances of dogs in the North. Several forms of archaeological and genetic evidence make this abundantly clear. First, dogs in the North underwent a series of dietary adaptations due to domestication, most of them long after they first emerged in relationships with people. Second, the body masses of dogs in portions of the North shifted through time and varied by place. This likely indicates long-term adaptation to human-dominated food environments, and human selection for dogs of certain body sizes. Finally, human selection processes that clearly shaped the evolutionary history of dogs are well evidenced in the archaeological record of the North. Most notable are examples of breeding outcomes, namely the culling of dogs before they reach reproductive age.   

12:10 PM: The Variable Histories of Reindeer Scapulae in Arctic Siberia
Presentation format:
Author(s):
  • Tatiana Nomokonova - University of Saskatchewan
  • Andrei Plekhanov - Scientific Center of Arctic Studies
  • Andrei Gusev - Scientific Center of Arctic Studies

Animal scapulae are widely incorporated into Indigenous lifeways across the Circumpolar North, especially as hide working tools, fish knives, and divination devices. This is particularly the case for the Iamal Peninsula of Arctic Siberia, where reindeer scapula tools are among the most abundant groups of implements found during archaeological excavations of two Iron Age sites, namely Iarte VI and Ust’-Polui. This presentation addresses the histories of the reindeer scapulae based on the materials from these two sites. The Iarte VI settlement contained almost 290 scapula tools that appear to have been used for softening and straightening reindeer skin straps for ropes and lassos. Excavation at Ust’-Polui produced over 250 fish knives made from this skeletal element. We will explore how this one particular skeletal element was separated from the other parts of the animal body, which scapulae were chosen for tool production, how they were transformed into objects of interest and use, and how they ultimately became important links in the chains of people-reindeer relationships in this region. We further discuss how reindeer scapulae are embedded into perceptions of wild and domestic reindeer and involved in a variety of social and material practices in this region.

12:20 PM: The Eneolithic and Bronze Age Animal Imagery from the Iamal Region of Arctic Siberia
Presentation format:
Author(s):
  • Daniel Tupakhin - Arctic Research Center of Yamal-Nenets Autonomus District
  • Olga Tupakhina - Arctic Research Center of Yamal-Nenets Autonomus District

This presentation introduces animal imagery that was found at a few archaeological sites of the Arctic and subarctic sections of the Iamal region of northwest Siberia during the Eneolithic and Bronze Age. Some of the imagery styles are quite unique for this region, particularly in terms of their chronological span and geographical distribution. Most of the animal imagery was made on clay objects, especially ceramic vessels. These images include a variety of avian and mammalian species, particularly waterfowl, raptors (owls), terrestrial carnivores (e.g., possibly mustelids, bears, canids), ungulates (e.g., moose), and sea mammals (seals). We further compare the range of animal species depicted in imagery from this period to the results of identifications of faunal remains recovered during excavations of the archaeological site Gornyi Samotnel - 1. This settlement is considered one of the earliest and most intriguing Eneolithic sites in this region because of its good stratigraphic preservation, remains of a dwelling, over 30,000 artefacts, ~500 animal remains, and many animal images depicted on rims and walls of its ceramic vessels.

12:30 PM: Animals in Early Iron Imagery from the Iamal Region of Arctic Siberia
Presentation format:
Author(s):
  • Andrey Gusev - Arctic Research Center of Yamal-Nenets Autonomus district
  • Natalia Fedorova - Arctic Research Center of Yamal-Nenets Autonomus district

This presentation introduces a wide range of animal images found at the Ust’-Polui site in the Iamal region of Arctic Siberia.  Excavations at this site have produced a broad assortment of organic materials that have been particularly well preserved in the permafrost areas of the site’s cultural deposits. Ust’-Polui is a well-known archaeological location in north-western Siberia that had been used for community gatherings and sacral activities by Indigenous populations living in the Lower Ob River area from the third century BCE to the second century CE. The Ust’-Polui animal imagery includes approximately 140 objects of metal, antler, birch bark, wood, and stone. The animal images were carved on handles of spoons, knives, and awls and were depicted on combs, a variety of metal pendants, and other objects. The majority depict birds, especially waterfowl, but also raptors and owls. Waterfowl are often depicted as floating in water; raptors are depicted in profile and often as eating the heads of artiodactyls. Most of the mammals depicted are reindeer with a few having open mouths and protruding tongues. Other items contain images of possible mustelids, beavers, and bears.

12:50 PM: Animal Imagery from Medieval Sites of the Iamal Region of Arctic Siberia
Presentation format:
Author(s):
  • Andrey Plekhanov - Arctic Research Center of Yamal-Nenets Autonomus district
  • Alexander Gusev - Arctic Research Center of Yamal-Nenets Autonomus district

Animal imagery was often used to embellish items utilized by the many populations inhabiting Western Siberia during the Holocene. This is especially the case for bronze items made by medieval populations inhabiting the Iamal and Gydan peninsulas and forest-steppe zone of northwestern Siberia from 9 to 14th centuries CE. This presentation discusses artefacts with animal imagery found during the excavations of three medieval cemeteries, Zelenyi Iar, Iur-Iakha 3, Parisento, and the settlement Iarte 6. Excavations at these sites produced 21 objects with images of waterfowl, bear, fur-bearing animals, horse, hare, reindeer, and fish. Many of the animal images appear on bracelets, pendants, knife handles, and sheaths. One of the most common motifs of this time was the image of a bear’s head laying between its front paws, most often found on metal bracelets. It is noticeable that decorated knife and sheath sets played an important role in indicating an individual’s social status. This stands in contrast with findings of ancient imagery from previous periods, when animals often reflected subsistence patterns rather than being markers for social status within local communities.

01:00 PM: Dashing Through The Snow: Activity Reconstruction of Reindeer Hooves in Fennoscandian Archaeology
Presentation format:
Author(s):
  • Emily Hull - University of Oulu
  • Anna-Kaisa Salmi - University of Oulu

The use and husbandry of reindeer in Fennoscadia has been an area of increasing interest in zooarchaeology, especially in both Arctic and Human-Animal Studies. The historical record and recent research has shown that mixed subsistence existence was practiced by the Sámi peoples from at least the 14th century. The reindeer in these communities included a combination of herded, hunted, and working reindeer. Research of phalangeal entheseal changes (ECs) has shown definable differences between wild forest reindeer (R.t. fennicus) and domestic barren ground reindeer (R.t. tarandus). Analysis of pathological changes and long bone ECs has revealed skeletal changes typical to working reindeer. In this paper, we analyze phalangeal ECs of reindeer from three Sámi sites, Juikenttä, Nukkumajoki, and Autiokenttä, located in Finland. Research into pathology and ECs of reindeer long bones from these sites is consistent with a pattern of a mixture of herded, working, and wild animals. The movements of the reindeer hooves give further evidence to both animal lives and human husbandry, and we have therefore undertaken a comparative analysis of modern phalangeal ECs with all three sites. This work helps to provide archaeological evidence for Sámi subsistence patterns as well as human-animal relationships of the past.

01:10 PM: Human – Animal Relationships from the Perspective of Historic Caribou and Sheep Fences in the Mackenzie Mountains, Northwest Territories
Presentation format:
Author(s):
  • Glen MacKay - Prince of Wales Northern Heritage Centre

The archaeological record of the central Mackenzie Mountains – the homeland of Shúhtagoťine (Mountain Dene) hunter-gatherers – contains several examples of historic communal hunting structures used to funnel animals towards kill sites. The remnants of these features, including their strategic placement in the landscape, encompass a large body of Shúhtagoťine traditional ecological knowledge related to the movements and behavior of mountain caribou and sheep. The relationship of the Shúhtagoťine with the animals they hunt also structure the material records of these sites, and may explain the relative absence of faunal remains near the fence features. Indigenous place names and other contextual information illuminate the role of communal hunting structures in Shúhtagoťine land use in the central Mackenzie Mountains in the recent and more distant past.

01:20 PM: Furs and Food Stuffs: Thule Inuit use of Arctic Fox at Arviq, N.W.T., Canada
Presentation format:
Author(s):
  • Adrianna Wiley - University of Guelph
  • Lisa Hodgetts - Western University

While Thule Inuit exploitation of Ringed seal and caribou is well documented, their use of Arctic fox (Alopex lagopus) remains understudied. This paper combines evidence from ethnohistory, ethnography, and zooarchaeology to better understand Arctic fox use in a dwelling at the ca. 1550 AD site of Arviq (OkRn-1), Banks Island, Northwest Territories. While cutmark analysis from Arviq supports exploitation of fox for pelts, it also suggests at least some foxes were used for food. This interpretation is supported by epiphyseal fusion evidence indicating some fox harvesting occurred in the late summer and/or fall, when Arctic foxes would still have had summer coats, which were not used in clothing. Additionally, human-fox relationships at the site had a symbolic or spiritual element, suggested by a cluster of fox skulls in a shallow pit within the dwelling. Comparison with the earlier site of Nelson River (OhRh-1) indicates Arctic fox have played an important role in Inuit subsistence on Banks Island throughout its occupational history, a practice that continued into the recent past. Fox may have been a key resource for mitigating periodic food shortages in the Amundsen Gulf region, which does not have the same resource richness as surrounding Arctic regions

01:40 PM: What Muskrat Told Me: Zooarchaeological Evidence for Early Muskrat-Human Relationships in the Inuvialuit Settlement Region
Presentation format:
Author(s):
  • Danii Desmarais - University of Toronto

Muskrats have been an important aspect of human lifeways in the Inuvialuit Settlement Region (ISR) since time immemorial, and they continue to play an important role in Inuvialuit culture today.  A focus on the importance of larger prey species in ancestral Inuvialuit subsistence practices has tended to overshadow the significance of the modest muskrat, despite the luxurious and technologically advantageous nature of their hides. This paper outlines my preliminary efforts at understanding early Inuvialuit-muskrat relationships, and how that relationship might have evolved through time. Particular attention is paid to the nature of muskrat remains recovered from the archaeological record, and how this small rodent played a supporting role in ancestral Inuvialuit lifeways. Following a relationality approach to communicating Indigenous archaeology, I discuss my interpretations through the lens of my relationships with muskrat, community, the land, and research.

01:50 PM: Being with Bison in Beaver Territory
Presentation format:
Author(s):
  • Jessica Metcalfe - Lakehead University
  • Elizabeth Carpenter - Lakehead University
  • Victoria Wanihadie - Tsattine Resurgence Society

Since time immemorial, Beaver people have lived in the Peace region of northwestern Alberta and northeastern British Columbia. The Peace region is located in an ecological transition zone where northern and southern populations of wood and plains bison intermingled until the near-extinction of bison in the late 19th century. Archaeologists are well aware that communal bison hunting was widespread on the Great Plains, particularly in the northern Plains (southern Alberta, Saskatchewan, and Montana), for thousands of years. In contrast, a recent review of buffalo jumps, pounds, and arroyo traps included a total of zero sites in the Peace region, and there is a perception among some scholars that such sites do not extend that far north. However, Beaver oral histories clearly indicate that communal bison hunting was a societal norm, which implies that communal hunting strategies were utilized in Beaver territory. We describe a project in its initial stages that seeks to investigate communal bison hunting in Beaver territory using archival, ethnohistorical, oral historical, ecological, and field-based approaches.

02:00 PM: Living with trees in the early Holocene forests of Northern Europe
Presentation format:
Author(s):
  • Barry Taylor - University of Chester

The past two decades have seen a growing body of research into the ways in which animals were perceived by the human communities inhabiting the early Holocene forests of northern Europe. This work has come to see the relationship between humans and animals in cultural terms, exploring the ontological significance of particular species, and how this is reflected in the way animal bodies were treated and disposed of.

This paper argues that human-plant relationships were situated within the same ontological perspectives. In a series of case studies from the North European Mesolithic, it will show how trees, and materials from trees, were subject to particular forms of treatment and deposition, comparable to that of the remains of animals. In doing so, it will argue that both plants and animals were active constituents in the worldviews of human communities, were bound up in people’s cosmologies, and imbued with a significance that went beyond their role as a source of food or raw material.