Archaeology on the Brink: Celebrating the Career of Jack Brink

Session Hosting Format: 
in-person session
Date/Time: 
Friday, April 29, 2022 - 8:20am to 5:00pm
(CST)
Room: 
British Columbia Room
Organizer(s): 
  • Bill Byrne, Government of Alberta (retired)
  • Ray LeBlanc, University of Alberta (retired)
  • Eric Damkjar, Archaeological Survey of Alberta (retired)
Contact Email: 
Session Description (300 word max): 

In his 40 years with the Archaeological Survey of Alberta and as Curator of Archaeology at the Royal Alberta Museum (now emeritus), Jack Brink has undertaken ground-breaking field research across Alberta, produced many publications and presentations for professional and avocational audiences, played a formative role in the development of cultural resource management policy in Alberta, been a creative and driving force in the establishment of world-class interpretive facilities and public programs, provided encouragement and facilitated opportunities for many students and colleagues, and fostered meaningful and lasting partnerships with Indigenous groups and individuals. 

Jack’s most important fieldwork involves the archaeology of communal bison hunting. For more than 25 years, he led a program of research at Head-Smashed-In Buffalo Jump, significantly expanding our understanding of strategic elements of the hunt and of subsequent meat processing decisions and activities. Jack’s other archaeological passion is Indigenous rock art -- Jack has probably studied every significant rock art site in Alberta, developing state-of-the-art technologies to document and to protect this vulnerable and unique record of cultural expression. Jack has consistently approached his research with great dedication, originality, collegiality and respect for Indigenous knowledge and sensibility that informs his study of the archaeological record.

Jack’s career and personality are infused with collegiality, humour and a sense of joy in what he does. This session is an opportunity for friends and colleagues to honour Jack through presentations of original research and through reminiscences and observations on shared experiences and friendships.

Presentations
08:40 AM: An Introduction to the Archaeology of the Kakwa Region in the North Alberta Rocky Mountains
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Darryl Bereziuk - Archaeological Survey of Alberta

The northern Alberta Rocky Mountains near Grande Cache remain the least known archaeological region in Alberta’s mountain system. An introduction to the archaeology of the Grande Cache region was provided by Jack Brink who led an archaeological survey and excavation program of the major lake and river systems during the mid- to late-1970’s. This work provided an initial characterization of the archaeological record associated with the transitional montane environment of the upper Smoky River valley near Grande Cache. Thirty years later, the Archaeological Survey of Alberta engaged upon another multi-year archaeological survey in the region, this time focusing on high elevation alpine and sub-alpine environments of the Kakwa region to the west of Grande Cache. This paper presents the results of helicopter-assisted, exploratory reconnaissance of this previously unexplored area of the Rocky Mountain Natural Region, characterizes the identified archaeological sites, and explores geographical constraints and cultural motives that may have influenced precontact settlement and land use patterns within this remote mountainous region.

09:00 AM: The Finer Features of the Junction Site
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Brian Vivian - Lifeways of Canada
  • Janet Blakey - Lifeways of Canada

This paper reports on the success of three seasons of excavation at the Junction Site, where anomalies identified through the use of a magnetometer became focal points for the mitigative excavations completed.  Here we assess the utility of this technique (and other remote sensing techniques tested) in identifying buried features and further describe the many different features exposed.   Our discussion concludes with an analysis of results and identification of the salient characteristics which distinguish the different functions of the features identified.

09:20 AM: A Remarkable Pit Feature at Head-Smashed-In Buffalo Jump
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Eric Damkjar - Archaeological Survey of Alberta (retired)

The Head-Smashed-In-Buffalo Jump (HSI) site complex consists of three main functional components: the gathering basin and drive-lanes where animals were driven to the cliff edge; the jump or kill site, where they met their end and primary butchering took place; and the processing area on the level prairie below where meat and bone were further processed for immediate consumption and for longer-term storage. These latter activities are represented in the numerous features found in the processing area, such as hearths, boiling pits, roasting pits, and concentrations of fire-broken rock. While it is not always possible to assign specific function, the vast majority of features appear to have been utilitarian in purpose. However, a large and unusual pit feature appears to be an exception. Over a metre in depth, the pit contained over 8700 bone fragments, almost a thousand being identifiable elements, and numerous artifacts including Avonlea projectile points, substantial portions of a large ceramic vessel, ochre-covered bones, and two bison mandible spatualte artifacts, unique at HSI. This remarkable feature will be described and some interpretive thoughts offered.

09:40 AM: The Recovery of a 1,600 Year Old Roasting Pit Feature from Head-Smashed-In Buffalo Jump
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Bob Dawe - Royal Alberta Museum
  • Carmen Li - Royal Alberta Museum
  • Darren Tanke - Royal Tyrrell Museum

Key words: roasting pit feature, Head-Smashed-In Buffalo Jump, plaster jacketing

Abstract: More than a hundred pre-contact pit features have been recorded during the excavations of the processing area at Head-Smashed-In Buffalo Jump. In 1990 a largely intact 1,600 year old roasting pit feature was located and left in situ as it was considered a good candidate for potential future display. In 2016 the feature was recovered to exhibit in the new Royal Alberta Museum in Edmonton. Using a technique commonly used by paleontologists for fossil recovery the feature was excavated, and enclosed in a plaster jacket. After transport, the final excavation of the feature was accomplished in the museum, allowing optimal excavation conditions that produced some startling results. This methodology allows the preservation and long term interpretation of archaeological material, and provides an alternative to dismantling these features as a consequence of standard archaeological research investigation.

10:00 AM: The 2021 Excavations at Head-Smashed-In Buffalo Jump, UNESCO World Heritage Site: Taking Jack Brink’s Excavations to a New Level
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Shawn Bubel - University of Lethbridge
  • Kevin McGeough - University of Lethbridge
  • Robert Dawe - Royal Alberta Museum

Decades of archaeological excavations, research, and aboriginal consultation have revealed the complex history of Head-Smashed-In Buffalo Jump. Jack Brink is one of these researchers and a major accomplishment of his was developing an extensive understanding of what has come to be called “the processing area”. In 2016, a team from the Royal Alberta Museum returned to the processing area to remove a roasting pit that had been left intact by the earlier excavations. They recovered cultural material from a context that had been presumed to be below occupation levels. Radiocarbon dates on bone from this excavation proved to be the earliest dated cultural material recovered at the site, and older than the first presumed use of the site as a buffalo jump. In 2021, a joint team from the University of Lethbridge and the Royal Alberta Museum returned to the site to further explore this early use of the processing area, continuing the excavations started by Brink. While the area investigated was limited and materials discovered were minimal, the results were stunning, revealing that activities here have been occurring for more than 8,500 years. These results are presented as a tribute to Jack’s contributions to Head-Smashed-In Buffalo Jump.

10:40 AM: Microbotanical Remains, Residues, and Usewear: Other Views of Head-Smashed-In Buffalo Jump
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Brian Kooyman - Anthropology and Archaeology, University of Calgary

Head-Smashed-In Buffalo Jump is one of the best-known archaeological sites in Canada and a UNESCO World Heritage site. A great deal has been written about it, including by Jack Brink, and the site’s excavations and remains have contributed greatly to our understanding of bison hunting on the Great Plains. This paper examines phytoliths, charcoal, lithic tool residues and usewear to cast new cultural and paleoenvironmental light on this remarkable site.

11:00 AM: Stories from Head-Smashed-In Buffalo Jump (DkPj-1): An Interview with Boyd Wettlaufer
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Karen Giering - Royal Alberta Museum

Boyd Wettlaufer carried out the first systematic excavations at Head-Smashed-In Buffalo Jump in 1949. Stories from Wettlaufer himself describe how he first came to work at the site, where he discovered some Paleoindian artifacts and what he thought they indicated. Wettlaufer also described his relations with the local population, both Indigenous and non-Indigenous. The presence of the Paleoindian artifacts, as well as certain landscape features, suggests the site was used as a bison kill as long ago as 9000 BP. Several of these artifacts are made of exotic raw materials suggesting that the people present at Head-Smashed-In were involved in the trade and movement of raw materials which are not native to Alberta.

11:20 AM: For What It’s Worth/Please Prove Me Wrong: Thoughts from a Recovering Archaeologist
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Brian Spurling

You step away to follow other career interests, reconnect with old friends 25 years later and ... boom ... things really changed.  Over this discontinuity, the profession truly busted out of universities and museums for opportunities in consultancies, government, and NGOs.  Prospective practitioners don’t see archaeology as “the gateway drug” to the hard sciences anymore.  A new generation is leaning into societal relevance and agency, focusing on partnerships, progressive reforms, decolonization, advancing indigenization and responding to the heavy responsibilities of helping investigate the missing children.  More subjectively constructed, humanistic narratives are populating the archaeological record.  Challenges to the trope of humanity’s ineluctable march to inequity and constraint, along with case studies with lessons for the Anthropocene, are having their moment.  All to the good.  But there’s been scant progress on some vital legacy problems.   Peak archaeology has surely passed.   Resource loss far exceeds meaningful conservation, and no oversight or governance exists to measure, much less mitigate this.  And where are the communicators effectively amplifying archaeology’s value in the public square?  Like Jack Brink.  The discipline needs to level up or risk reverting to a small, precarious enterprise, ill-equipped to face climate change, relentless development, fierce competition for funding, and indifference.

01:20 PM: Newly Identified Red Ochre Handprint at Sandstone Ranch along the Milk River in Southern Alberta
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Trevor Peck - Circle CRM Group Inc.
  • Caroline Hudecek-Cuffe - Archaeological Survey of Alberta

In 2017, Archaeological Survey staff investigated claims of rock art being present on a sandstone outcrop at Sandstone Ranch, lands owned and managed jointly by the Nature of Conservancy of Canada, the Alberta Conservation Association, and the Alberta Fish and Game Association. Sandstone Ranch is situated within the Milk River Ridge natural area, encompassing native grasslands that support livestock grazing and a wide diversity of wildlife along the Milk River in southern Alberta. A preliminary visit to the outcrop resulted in the identification of several red ochre smears and at least one partial handprint. This paper will discuss this newly identified rock art and how it relates to the distribution of other red ochre handprints and smears in Plains rock art.

01:40 PM: A Method for Detecting and Monitoring Changes to the Okotoks Erratic – “Big Rock” Provincial Historic Site.
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Peter Dawson - Anthropology and Archaeology, University of Calgary
  • Jack Brink - Royal Alberta Museum (retired)
  • Alireza  Farrokhi - Alberta Culture and Status of Women
  • Fengman Jia - Geomatics Engineering, University of Calgary
  • Derek Lichti - Geomatics Engineering, University of Calgary

When it comes to exploring how new technologies can be used to document, protect, and preserve rock art sites in Alberta, Jack Brink has been a true innovator. He was one of the first researchers to use terrestrial laser scanning to digitally capture rock art panels at Writing on Stone Provincial Park, and in 2013 he helped organize the scanning of the Okotoks Big Rock. With Jack’s help and encouragement, we demonstrate how 3D laser scanning can be used to detect and monitor changes at this highly significant Provincial Historic Site using scanning data acquired over a period of 7 years. Point clouds of the erratic captured in 2013, 2016, and 2020 were compared using change detection analysis, revealing the movement/repositioning of rocks and emergence of "unofficial" paths around the base of the erratic, along with changes to fencing and interpretive trails. These results are encouraging and suggest this method may be an effective way to monitor heritage sites over time.

02:00 PM: Jack Brink, the Milk River, and Writing-on-Stone / Áísínai’pi: A Non-humorous Story of Humanity in Southern Alberta
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Todd Kristensen - Archaeological Survey of Alberta
  • Terra Lekach - Independent

Jack Brink is not so different from the Milk River at the edge of southern Alberta. Not just because he meanders endlessly but because his career has crossed international boundaries, and, like the river, he too is old. The Milk River flows through Writing-on-Stone / Áísínai’pi, a UNESCO World Heritage Site known for its impressive collection of rock art within a sacred cultural landscape of the modern Niitsítapi (Blackfoot). Jack Brink’s career has been interwoven with the site since the 1970s. This paper is a story of archaeology and connection along the Milk River.

02:20 PM: Reconciling Local, Global, and Indigenous Values: Lessons from the World Heritage Inscription of the Writing-on-Stone / Áísínai’pi Cultural Landscape
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Michael A. Klassen - Klahanee Heritage Research

After a nomination process lasting 15 years, Writing-on-Stone / Áísínai’pi was designated a World Heritage Site in 2019. From inception to inscription, Jack Brink was instrumental in making this designation happen, inspiring and encouraging a dedicated team of Blackfoot advisors and Alberta Parks employees. Although this inscription recognizes the international significance of this Blackfoot cultural landscape, the nomination process also exposed dissonance between local, global, and Indigenous values. Blackfoot perspectives emphasize the ancient and sacred connection to the broader landscape, while remaining inclusive of settler society’s recent historical relationship to the place. Conversely, the historical Euro-Canadian presence highlighted weaknesses in the nomination, while local community concerns impacted the effectiveness of the proposed boundary and buffer zone. In consequence, international experts struggled to reconcile globalized universalism with local perspectives and Indigenous values. Throughout the nomination, Jack helped the team navigate this contested landscape and politicized history, ultimately leading to a successful but imperfect inscription – one that still circumscribes the contemporary Indigenous relationship to this site. Although the World Heritage nomination process accrued many tangible benefits for Writing-on-Stone / Áísínai’pi, the potential of this inscription for advancing reconciliation with Indigenous peoples has yet to be fully realized.

02:40 PM: Archaeological Survey of Alberta Occasional Paper No. 99: The Last Waltz (Revisited)
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • David Burley - Dept of Archaeology, Simon Fraser University

Archaeological Survey of Alberta Occasional Paper No. 99 was released in 1991, a publication neither paid for or recognized by the government of Alberta. In the face of substantial government cuts to the Survey with survivors sent to the Provincial Museum, Jack Brink and remaining comrades produced a retrospective of ASA highlights between 1973 and 1991. The volume was not a doom and gloom tirade in the wake of decimation, as normal folks might write. Instead, it was an 18-year concatenation of collegial comradery, stupid stories, holiday antics, and significant memories. I revisit Occasional Paper 99 and the central role Jack Brink played in the almost two-decade period it documents.

03:20 PM: The Early Precontact Period at the Ahai Mneh Site (FiPp-33), near Lake Wabamun. Alberta
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • John W. (Jack) Ives - University of Alberta

When Jack Brink and I were MA students at the University of Alberta in 1975, I applied spatial analytical methods to disentangle artifact distributions at an important site type in Alberta: those with rich lithic records, but highly compressed stratigraphy.  Archaeologists working at these sites run the risk of associating artifacts merely because they occur near each other. Natural disturbances in thinly stratified deposits mean artifacts found near each other can easily come from different time periods. In our 2010-2012 research at Ahai Mneh in central Alberta, we returned to these issues and were able to identify a deeper Paleo-Indigenous period component, also present in surface collections from an adjacent cultivated field. Enigmatic and initially unprepossessing artifacts from Ahai Mneh actually have fascinating stories to tell if we are willing to delve into the microcosm of human decisions for which they still preserve traces. Examples include a failed effort at making a fluted point, an unusual Hell Gap-like point, a Scottsbluff point, and a fractured Alberta point base. While the results of such analyses involve inferences, they are much better than casual assumptions about associations, and point to the need for serious regulatory reform in requiring 3-D piece-plotting of artifacts.

 

03:40 PM: Do We Know Jack About Microblades in Canada?
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Martin Magne - Independent Scholar

The literature on microblade technology world-wide has become voluminous. In Canada our understanding of its origins, permutations, and significance have developed considerably since MacNeish, Sanger, Morlan, Borden and others started recognizing the variations that exist, some 60 years ago. A recent exchange with Jack revealed that despite his extensive archaeological experience and knowledge, he really knows nothing about microblades, prompting reflection about how microblades are commonly perceived by non-specialists. Based in part on patterns in Scandinavia and northwestern Europe where post-glacial and Neolithic microblades are abundant, I present conclusions about microblades in Canada and the northwest generally, outlining where more research and data would be productive.

04:00 PM: A Long Way from Home: Finds of Queen Conch (Strombus gigas) shells in central Alberta
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Alwynne  Beaudoin - Royal Alberta Museum
  • Diana Tirlea - Royal Alberta Museum
  • Samuel Owen - Royal Alberta Museum

In recent years, there have been several finds of Queen Conch (Strombus gigas) shells in central Alberta. Queen Conch is a marine gastropod mollusc that is widespread in the Caribbean and Gulf of Mexico, so these shells are clearly not of local origin. Their taxonomic identification is confirmed by the large size, thickness, ornamentation and morphology of the shells, and comparison with modern specimens. One specimen lacks its distinctive flange. Two were found in buried context – one shallow, one deep - that suggests probable archaeological significance, rather than chance modern discards. Their exact point of origin is unknown. However, one yielded a radiocarbon date of around 1000 RCYBP, with a marine reservoir correction assuming an origin near the mouth of the Mississippi. Conch meat was, and is, a valuable food resource in the Caribbean and Gulf region, as attested by shell mounds. Robust conch shell has been used as a tool material, with flange removal being a common form of tool production. Various marine shells are found in archaeological sites throughout the Mississippi watershed and beyond in interior North America. Pending confirmation, our hypothesis is that these specimens were traded or brought inland from the Gulf coast.

04:20 PM: I Don’t Know Jack
Presentation format: In-Person
Author(s):
  • Peter Ramsden - McMaster University

I have been repeatedly encouraged to contribute to a session entitled "Archaeology on the Brink: Celebrating the Career of Jack Brink", at this year's CAA conference. I was unaware that anybody of this name had a career, but I'm always up for a celebration. So I took it upon myself to investigate just who Jack Brink is, and where he fits into the scheme of things. My findings, as I reveal them in this presentation, may surprise you.