Student Voices: Growing Communities Through Support and Collaboration (Short-Session)

Date/Time: 
Saturday, May 8, 2021 - 12:00pm to 2:00pm
(CST)
Room: 
3
Organizer(s): 
  • The CAA Student Committee [Kelsey Pennanen (University of Calgary), Molly Ingenmey (Memorial University of Newfoundland), Tekla Cunningham (University of Winnipeg)]
Contact Email: 
Session Description (300 word max): 

This session is aimed primarily at students, early-career researchers, and those interested in gaining presentation experience, to provide a platform for the budding archaeology community to plant roots through sharing their voice. Presenting at a conference for the first time can be leaf-shaking, so this session will comprise shortened talks of ideas in blossom. Presentations for this session can involve a research project that has preliminary findings, the results of an honour’s thesis or independent project, a research proposal, a story from the field, a short history of your favourite object, a book review, a tasty field recipe, or ideas for archaeology quarantine activities- the only catch is your presentation must be given in only 5 minutes!

The presentations will be given synchronously using the webinar format to provide the most authentic experience to an in-person talk. Presentations will be grouped based on similarity in topic matter, so please provide a general description of the topic you will be discussing, in no more than 250 words, and submit it to the Abstract Submission Form on the CAA website. Visual components for presentations from accepted presenters will be limited to only 1-3 slides and will be requested prior to the presentation date to allow for compilation and smooth transition between presentations. A synchronous question-and-answer period will be offered at the end of the session for time to connect with presenters. If you have any questions please feel free to reach out to caa.students@gmail.com. We look forward to your submission and hearing your valuable perspectives and insights!

Presentations
12:10 PM: Archaeology, Storytelling, and Resilience: A Case Study from the Greater Antilles
Presentation format:
Author(s):
  • Tekla Cunningham - University of Winnipeg

Through archaeological analysis, the lives of people living hundreds of years ago can be better understood. By studying the material remains that they left behind and through different analyses, we can uncover more about what their lives looked like and how they interacted with the world. Archaeology is used to tell stories about the lives of people from long ago. This storytelling can help us understand more about their resilience and capabilities. Often, misperceptions about the abilities of people, especially Indigenous peoples, are still promoted due to colonial legacies, obscuring their true knowledge and capabilities. This is true in the Caribbean, where the writings by colonizers still shape current perceptions about the Indigenous peoples of the islands. However, through archaeological analyses, more is being uncovered about their lives. Telling their stories helps combat those misperceptions and shares with the world the reality of their knowledge and resilience. The Caribbean has been inhabited for thousands of years and the inhabitants in the past must have been capable and resilient, yet this has been obscured due to colonial misperceptions. Through archaeology, the truth about their lives can be uncovered and told, and their resilience and strength can be better understood.

12:15 PM: Whales and Whaling: A Guide to Traditional Whaling (website)
Presentation format:
Author(s):
  • Susannah  Clinker - McGill University
  • Robyn  Nakano - McGill University

In the last century, whaling has quickly become one of the most controversial subsistence practices across the globe. At the frontlines of this dispute are various Indigenous whaling communities that continue to practice traditional whaling and anti-whaling advocates. While both sides make passionate cases for their cause, the unfortunate truth is that the sheer influence and power large anti-whaling campaigns wield often drown out the voices of Indigenous whaling societies who continue to rely on whales for sustenance and cultural identity. Not only are the motivations behind traditional whaling often neglected by anti-whaling campaigns, facts about their environmental and socio-economic impact are also skewed to serve their conservation interests. To confront this imbalance and the general colonial undertones of anti-whaling campaigns, we present this website that provides straight-forward facts about whales, whaling and the significance of traditional whaling for two case studies (Japan and Faroe Islands). With all the information at their disposal, the general public is encouraged to consider traditional whaling and whale conservation not as opposing efforts but, rather, as efforts that would benefit from alliance. 

12:20 PM: Environmental Impacts of 18th Century British Colonial Worldviews: A Small-Scale Example from a British Military Fort in Southern Ontario
Presentation format:
Author(s):
  • Keira McCartney - McMaster University

Excavations at Old Fort Erie, a British Colonial fort built in the 1760’s and landscape used as a battleground during the War of 1812, have been conducted as part of Wilfrid Laurier University's archaeology field school. Identification of the faunal remains associated with the Old Fort show evidence for varied diet and land use during the time between the Fort’s building to the construction of the New Fort (1764-1805). As the first British Fort in what is now Ontario, Old Fort Erie’s archaeological assemblage provides a small-scale look at the development of British colonial worldviews in the area and the consequences of their transplantation. Changes in environmental pressures on aquatic and terrestrial resources caused by colonial presence in the area contributed the extirpations and extinctions seen across the continent. Passenger Pigeons (Ectopistes migratorius) and Lake Ontario Salmon (Salmo salar) are two examples of this phenomenon evidenced to have been exploited at Old Fort Erie. Archaeological evidence at Old Fort Erie suggests that the people inhabiting the Fort between 1764 and 1805 took advantage of what they would have seen as a “pristine land”, exploiting a wide variety of species without regard for the future consequences.

12:25 PM: A New Approach for Assessing Harvesting Pressure of Shellfish From Archaeological Sites in Nova Scotia.
Presentation format:
Author(s):
  • Ian  Predham - Memorial University

Marine bivalves from archaeological sites can reveal critical information about past environments and human impacts on shellfish populations, specifically harvesting strategies. Identifying the age and season of shellfish collection demonstrates how often shellfish were harvested and when a site was being occupied. Previous research on Mya arenaria from archaeological shell midden deposits demonstrated the potential of this species for seasonality studies. However, variation in individual and population growth rates, coupled with issues of preservation makes this species difficult to analyze. Thin-section analysis of seasonal growth bands is unreliable, however, reliable age estimates can be made. The variation in growth rates and variability between populations makes interpreting seasonality from shell growth unreliable. This research presents an alternative way to assess the age-at-death from M. arenaria and proposes that counting annual growth rings is a reliable way to interpret the long-term history of shellfish harvesting in Nova Scotia.  

12:30 PM: Size Matters: The Applicability of Scuffage at Wintering Sites in the Northern Plains
Presentation format:
Author(s):
  • Zoe Cascadden - University of Calgary

Scuffage predicts that artifacts discarded on the floors of domestic or high-traffic spaces will be kicked, broken, or pushed into the ground depending on the artifact’s location and size prior to site abandonment. This theory and the impacts on artifact distribution has been explored in experimental studies, but there is limited research on its applicability to the soils and domestic sites of the Northern plains.  By examining the location of artifacts found in datable levels at the tipi ring sites EgPn-377 and EgPn-375, there are indications that the artifact distribution patterns found in those experimental scuffage studies can be seen in wintering household contexts in the Foothills of the Rocky Mountains.

12:35 PM: A Story of Paleolithic Occupations: Understanding Neanderthal and Homo sapiens Spatial Organization at Riparo Bombrini
Presentation format:
Author(s):
  • Amélie Vallerand - Université de Montréal

The site of Riparo Bombrini (Liguria, Italy) offers a unique setting to compare the spatial organization of Neanderthal and Homo sapiens occupations in a single archaeological site. The disappearance of the Neanderthals is one of the greatest debates in prehistory since the period of their decline corresponds to the arrival of Homo sapiens in Europe. It is thus often assumed that fundamental differences distinguish the two populations, and the ability to structure space within the sites they occupied into distinct activity areas is often invoked as a key distinctive trait of our species. However, this behavior has never been assessed for both groups at a single site, making direct comparisons impossible so far. This project thus aims to objectively evaluate the degree of spatial organization in the earliest Protoaurignacian levels (A1-A2, associated with Homo sapiens) as well as the latest Mousterian levels (MS1-MS2, associated with Neanderthals) at Riparo Bombrini. Combining GIS and quantitative methods allow the study of the spatial distribution of artefacts and features in these levels, showing that Neanderthals indeed organized their living spaces like Homo sapiens. This contributes new data to the ongoing debates over ‘behavioral modernity,’ suggesting it is not limited to our species alone.

12:40 PM: Leukoma staminea: A New Proxy for Seasonality and Palaeotemperature for Coastal British Columbia
Presentation format:
Author(s):
  • Sarah Kuehn - Memorial University of Newfoundland

This study tests the feasibility of Leukoma staminea as a new proxy for past sea surface temperature (SST) and seasonality from shell middens in coastal British Columbia (BC). Three live L. staminea clams were collected from the Sechelt Inlet in Sechelt, BC, to calibrate stable oxygen isotope values with current climatic conditions. Samples for stable oxygen isotope analysis were collected sequentially to obtain a record of shell growth, beginning at the ventral margin and following the axis of growth. Five shells of both L. staminea and S. gigantea were analyzed from Powell River, BC, in the traditional territory of the Tla’amin First Nation. Results showed that L. staminea can be used as a proxy for SST and seasonality, and there is a seasonal emphasis on shellfish harvesting in the summer and autumn months. Reconstructed SST estimates showed a range of 5.1-18.9℃ for live-collected shells and 5.3-32.0℃ for the archaeologically collected shells. Palaeotemperature results of the archaeological shells show an overestimation of past SST, attributed to the dual effects of water temperature and salinity on shell oxygen isotope values.

12:45 PM: Ladies, Gentlemen, and [redacted]: A Nonbinary View of Feminist Archaeological Theory
Presentation format:
Author(s):
  • Kaitlyn Vanderkolk - University of Calgary

Feminist theory has been incredibly productive in its goal of bringing female voices to the forefront of archaeology, both of our subjects and of researchers themselves. Feminist archaeology has pursued the equalization of our field, pushing for non-gendered consideration for grants and equal opportunity to pursue research projects, as well as investigation into the roles and lives of women in the past. However, feminist theories have continued to perpetuate a western gender binary in practice and among its researchers. Nonbinary voices are still existing at the margins, if existing at all. In this paper, I aim to critique feminist and queer theories from a non-binary lens. Does feminist archaeology provide a platform for the understanding of nonbinary genders, third genders, even two-spirit genders? If not, how and where does it fail, and how can we improve our theories to encompass nonbinary experiences and perspectives?

01:00 PM: Radiocarbon Dating Marine Bivalve Mollusks: Best Practices for Calculating a Marine Reservoir Correction
Presentation format:
Author(s):
  • Marisa Dusseault - Memorial University of Newfoundland
  • Meghan  Burchell - Memorial University of Newfoundland
  • Kristin Poduska - Memorial University of Newfoundland

Bivalve mollusk shells, such as clams and mussels, incorporate naturally occurring carbon-14 from their marine environment into their calcium carbonate (CaCO3) structure as they grow and are commonly found at coastal archaeological sites. The quality of radiocarbon measurements depends on whether the CaCO3 has been altered chemically or structurally after death, how a sample is extracted from the shell, and how accurately the marine radiocarbon environment at the time of death can be reconstructed. This last factor requires applying a marine reservoir correction to the date which is a challenge to determine because it requires considering the species’ growth patterns and the variability of the marine environment. Most archaeological studies use a single radiocarbon measurement on a short-lived marine shell sample to calculate the correction while others complete high-resolution studies using long-lived samples that link multiple radiocarbon measurements from a single shell with other isotopic data that provides information about climate and human-environment interactions. Using radiocarbon measurements on archaeological shells of Saxidomus gigantea from Comox and Deep Bay, British Columbia as a case study, we highlight that developing robust, highly location-specific corrections through multiple sample measurements is necessary for interpreting radiocarbon dates accurately.

01:05 PM: Where did it all go?: Ontario Heritage Legislation and Professional Looting
Presentation format:
Author(s):
  • Tatjana Vieira

Most of the archaeological work that takes place in the province of Ontario is in the form of CRM. This “professional” archaeology follows the standards and guidelines provided by Ontario heritage legislation, which has long been criticized and critiqued by Indigenous communities due to its meager engagement and consultation requirements and lack of enforcement of minimum standards of practice. This legislation also has major effects on access to and ownership of heritage material as anything found during a project is entrusted to the archaeologist on behalf of the people of Ontario. This results in Indigenous heritage materials stored in boxes and bags in garages, basements, and storage lockers of Euro-Canadian archaeologists, completely unbeknownst to descendant relations. In this paper I will examine how the Ontario heritage legislation has created a system where archaeological material is continually excavated in the name of urban expansion, but final excavation reports and artifacts are virtually inaccessible leading to the extraction and hoarding of Indigenous heritage material that may be more appropriately referred to as “Professional Looting”.

01:10 PM: An Archaeology Girl in a Material World: How experimental archaeology can enhance an undergraduate degree
Presentation format:
Author(s):
  • Gillian Taylor - University of Calgary

Experimental archaeology can be a great way for students to learn and truly understand what they are learning in their classes. Dr. Matthew Walls put me in contact with Don Gardner, and I helped him facilitate a weekly experimental archaeology workshop from January to March, 2020, for undergraduate students to recreate Arctic material culture. We worked through numerous books on the subject, primarily The Frozen Saqqaq Sites of Disko Bay, West Greenland (2017) by Bjarne Grønnow, and working through the various tools and “nailing” down the methods behind their construction. We experimented with adzes, splitting wood, braiding sinew and crafting harpoons, among others. I will be using this experience, along with the flintknapping group that I am involved with, to illustrate how hands-on participation and learning can greatly complement and enhance an undergraduate archaeology degree.

01:15 PM: The ornaments of the Arma Veirana burial: using experimental archaeology to shed light on prehistoric social behaviors
Presentation format:
Author(s):
  • Catherine Brun - Université de Montréal

The 2017 discovery of an Early Mesolithic (10 000 – 9000 cal BP) newborn buried in Arma Veirana (Erli, Italy) is remarkable for its rarity and for the richness and diversity of its grave goods. Those are composed of 93 perforated Columbella rustica and 4 perforated Glycymeris sp. Studying these ornaments and how they were made is important because they reflect social norms about ornamentation among hunter-gatherers in Liguria at the dawn of the Holocene. The main purpose of the research presented in this paper is to study experimentally how these beads were manufactured, worn and integrated into ornaments. Experimental archaeology is an ideal approach for this work since it informs us about the whole array of possible physical constraints and techniques involved in the creation of shell ornaments, as well as allowing us to explore how physical movement affected the use-wear these beads accrued, opening interesting avenues of reflection about how links between the living and the dead were embodied in the Early Mesolithic. The results of this study thus can have implications for our understanding of the emergence of innovative behaviors, in particular early expressions of social hierarchy manifested by the development and transmission of hereditary social status.

01:20 PM: The Intricacies of Mortuary Practices in Early Hominin Populations
Presentation format:
Author(s):
  • Sydnye Berard - University of Winnipeg

A society’s burial practices can be quite telling of the population, in modern times and the past. My aim in this research is to explore the evidence and critiques of sites that are thought to contain intentional burials of early hominin populations. In examining the evidence found at Shanidar Cave in Kurdistan, Sima de los Huesos in Atapuerca, Spain, and Rising Star Cave in South Africa I explored evidence of intentional burial practices at each site and the critiques surrounding them. I also analyzed some of the alternative explanations for the burials and the downfalls of looking at the past through a modern lens. Even if these practices didn’t have the same meaning as modern-day funeral rites do to present human populations, the study of early burial practices brings a more relatable point of view to the study of ancient populations.

01:25 PM: Increasing Accessibility using Universal Design: A Case Study from Archaeology/Anthropology Department Websites
Presentation format:
Author(s):
  • Alexandra Ward - Department of Archaeology, Memorial University

Accessibility and universal design (UD) are often used as buzzwords without understanding how to apply the design principles. This study evaluates the accessibility and UD on archaeology department websites, through a survey of 12 archaeology and anthropology websites in Canada. The aim of the study is to evaluate what currently exists, and develop recommendations for integrating UD in university websites. Elements of inclusivity that recognise the colonial structure of universities and the disciplines of archaeology and anthropology were also evaluated. The results indicate that UD and accessibility on university websites is incredibly mixed, with the same website passing one criterion while failing another. In order to improve accessibility on archaeology department websites in Canada, those designing the website should be aware of the principles of UD and how to best apply them. This can include using forms of communication other than text, such as video, selecting appropriate colours and fonts, and using keyboard navigation with selection indicators. Effectively integrating UD into departmental websites will improve accessibility and sharing of information. With proper implementation, accessibility and UD can be far more than just buzzwords and become a meaningful part of university web design principles.